Listen to the article
President Trump’s recent claim that a Walmart Thanksgiving dinner package demonstrates his administration’s success in lowering prices requires closer examination, as the reality behind the discount tells a different story.
During a November 10 interview with Fox News’ Laura Ingraham, Trump pointed to Walmart’s $40 Thanksgiving dinner promotion as evidence of his economic policies working. He made similar remarks at a November 6 dinner with Central Asian leaders, stating there was “a 25% reduction in costs for Thanksgiving between Biden and me.”
The president, who campaigned heavily on addressing inflation, has frequently pushed back against discussions of rising grocery prices during his administration. This latest example involving Walmart’s holiday promotion appears misleading when analyzed in detail.
Walmart’s 2025 Thanksgiving dinner package costs $40, representing a $15 reduction from the $55 price tag of its 2024 promotion – a 27% decrease. However, this price drop doesn’t stem from lower-cost goods but rather from changes to the package contents.
Several staples remain consistent in both years’ promotions, including turkey, bread rolls, canned corn, gravy mix, pie crust, pumpkin, evaporated milk, and potatoes. The 2025 package added some new items: Stove Top brand stuffing, baby carrots, canned green beans, and macaroni and cheese.
Crucially, numerous items from the 2024 package were either eliminated or reduced in size. Removed items include chicken broth, fresh onions and celery, poultry seasoning, pecan pie, whipped topping, mini marshmallows, corn muffin mix, and three bags of sweet potatoes. Additionally, cranberries were downsized from a 14-ounce can to 12 ounces of fresh berries, mushroom soup was reduced from two cans to one, and crispy fried onions shrank from 6 ounces to 4.5 ounces.
An analysis of Walmart’s website prices as of November 12 shows that the additions to the 2025 package totaled $7.79 in value, while the subtractions and downsized products represented $24.35. This results in a net value reduction of approximately $16.56 – nearly matching the $15 price decrease.
“It is very unlikely that a typical household’s Thanksgiving shopping trip costs them 25% less than last year, unless they are feeding 25% fewer people or people are eating 25% less,” said Christopher Conlon, an economist at New York University’s Stern School of Business.
Federal data contradicts Trump’s broader implication about food prices. Grocery prices have actually increased by nearly 1.9% since he took office. While some items like eggs and bread have become cheaper, many others including meats, coffee, and sweets have risen in cost.
Retail experts caution against using a single retailer’s promotional strategy as evidence of broader economic trends. Major retailers like Walmart often employ “loss leader” tactics, selling certain high-visibility items at reduced prices to attract customers while making up the difference on other, higher-margin products.
“Holiday packages such as Walmart’s do not provide an accurate measure of year-on-year price changes but instead signal to consumers, ‘Shop here if you’re worried about prices,'” Conlon explained.
The White House did not respond to requests for comment on this matter.
In summary, while Walmart’s Thanksgiving dinner package price did indeed fall by approximately 25%, this reduction stems from offering fewer and smaller products rather than from declining food costs. The president’s claim connects this corporate marketing strategy to his economic policies in a way that misrepresents the underlying factors at work.
Fact Checker
Verify the accuracy of this article using The Disinformation Commission analysis and real-time sources.
10 Comments
The Walmart Thanksgiving dinner package price drop is an interesting data point, but the fact that it’s tied to changes in the contents rather than pure cost savings is an important distinction. I’d be curious to see a more comprehensive analysis of grocery price trends under the different administrations.
Yes, a broader look at grocery prices and inflation would provide much more meaningful context. Focusing on a single promotional item like this risks oversimplifying a complex economic issue.
This is a good example of why it’s important to look beyond the headline numbers when it comes to price comparisons. The changes in the Walmart Thanksgiving dinner package suggest the reality is more nuanced than the political narrative. I’m curious to see if further analysis uncovers any other relevant factors.
Agreed. Peeling back the layers and examining the details is crucial to getting an accurate understanding of these types of claims. It’s easy for politicians to cherry-pick data, so maintaining a critical eye is essential.
This highlights the need to carefully scrutinize claims about pricing, especially around political narratives. While a 27% drop in the Thanksgiving dinner package price sounds significant, the shift in contents is the real story. Fact-checking is crucial to get the full picture.
Well said. It’s easy for politicians to cherry-pick data points to support their claims, but the nuances often tell a different story. Maintaining a critical eye is important when evaluating these types of assertions.
The comparison between the Trump and Biden administrations’ impact on Thanksgiving costs is an interesting data point, but the details provided suggest it may not be as clear-cut as claimed. I look forward to seeing more in-depth analysis on the actual drivers behind the price changes.
Absolutely. Digging into the specifics around the package contents is key to understanding the real story here. Simplistic political claims often overlook important contextual factors.
Interesting to see the price changes for Walmart’s Thanksgiving dinner package. It’s always important to look at the details behind these kinds of claims to get the full picture. I’m curious to learn more about the changes in the contents that led to the 27% price drop.
Agreed, the details are key here. It would be helpful to understand exactly what items were removed or substituted in the 2025 package to get a better sense of the real drivers behind the price change.