Listen to the article
In the moments after Border Patrol agents dropped him off at a Buffalo doughnut shop, surveillance video captured Nurul Amin Shah Alam walking tentatively through an empty parking lot in jail-issued footwear. With his hood pulled up against the cold, the visually impaired refugee from Myanmar moved past a drive-thru window and disappeared into the night.
Five days later, Shah Alam, 56, was found dead on a downtown street, raising serious questions about federal protocols for releasing vulnerable detainees. The circumstances of his release – miles from home, without family notification, and with significant visual impairments – have sparked community outrage and calls for accountability.
The surveillance footage, obtained by local investigative news outlet Investigative Post, shows Shah Alam being released from a Border Patrol van at a Tim Hortons on February 19. Buffalo Mayor Sean Ryan confirmed the restaurant was closed at the time of the drop-off. The video shows Shah Alam approaching the locked front door after agents drove away.
U.S. Customs and Border Protection defended their actions, stating agents chose “a warm, safe location” for the release. However, critics question how a closed restaurant in freezing temperatures could be considered appropriate for a nearly blind man with limited English proficiency and no means of transportation.
Shah Alam’s body was discovered Tuesday outside KeyBank Center, home to the NHL’s Buffalo Sabres, several miles from the Tim Hortons. A passerby called 911 after finding him lying on the sidewalk. Buffalo police are reviewing citywide surveillance footage to reconstruct his movements in the days between his release and death.
The Erie County medical examiner is investigating the cause of death, which remains undetermined.
Border Patrol officials stated they offered Shah Alam “a courtesy ride” to a location near where his family had previously lived, adding that he accepted the ride and showed no signs of distress or disability. However, community advocates note that Shah Alam was blind in one eye with severely limited vision in the other, spoke virtually no English, and was unfamiliar with the area.
Benjamin Macaluso, an attorney with the Legal Aid Bureau of Buffalo who had been representing Shah Alam, reported him missing on Sunday. By that point, the family knew Shah Alam had been released from jail but had no information about his whereabouts. Macaluso searched immigration detention facilities, hospitals, and homeless shelters while distributing missing persons posters throughout Buffalo.
It wasn’t until Monday – nearly a week after the release – that Macaluso learned Shah Alam had been dropped at the Tim Hortons.
The circumstances leading to Shah Alam’s detention began in 2025, when police responded to a call about a trespasser. Body camera footage released by Buffalo Police shows officers approaching Shah Alam in a snowy backyard while he held what appeared to be curtain rods. Despite officers shouting commands he likely couldn’t understand, Shah Alam walked toward them with outstretched hands.
Advocates for the refugee community contend Shah Alam accidentally wandered onto private property and couldn’t comprehend police commands due to language barriers. The footage shows an escalation that included an officer threatening to shoot before deploying Tasers and forcing Shah Alam to the ground. Police reports indicate Shah Alam bit two officers during the struggle.
Initially charged with felony assault, burglary and criminal mischief, Shah Alam eventually pleaded guilty to two lesser misdemeanor charges on February 9. His legal team had initially advised against posting bail due to concerns about immigration detention, but after the plea agreement, they informed the family it was safe to secure his release.
After posting bond on February 19, Shah Alam was released from Erie County Holding Center. Following standard procedure, the sheriff’s office notified Border Patrol about his release due to an immigration detainer. Federal authorities determined Shah Alam wasn’t eligible for deportation and dropped him at the Tim Hortons that evening.
The case highlights significant gaps in coordination between criminal justice, immigration enforcement, and social service systems – particularly for vulnerable individuals with disabilities and language barriers. Community advocates are calling for policy changes to prevent similar tragedies in the future.
Fact Checker
Verify the accuracy of this article using The Disinformation Commission analysis and real-time sources.
8 Comments
The surveillance footage is quite disturbing. It’s unacceptable that Mr. Shah Alam was left in such a precarious situation, especially given his visual impairment. Federal authorities need to thoroughly investigate this incident and implement better procedures to protect vulnerable individuals.
Absolutely. The Border Patrol’s claim that this was a ‘warm, safe location’ seems very questionable given the video evidence and the tragic outcome. Transparency and accountability are crucial here.
This is a heartbreaking story. It’s deeply troubling that a disabled refugee could be abandoned in such a way, leading to his death just days later. The Border Patrol’s actions here seem highly questionable and demand a full, independent investigation.
This is a tragic situation. It’s deeply concerning that a visually impaired refugee was dropped off alone at a closed business, miles from his home. More oversight and compassion seems needed in how Border Patrol handles the release of vulnerable detainees.
I agree, the circumstances of this release raise serious questions about the protocol and decision-making process. Ensuring the safety and wellbeing of detainees should be the top priority.
This is a tragic and infuriating situation. The fact that a disabled refugee was essentially abandoned by the Border Patrol, leading to his death, is a complete and utter failure of the system. Significant changes are needed to protect vulnerable detainees.
The video footage is very disturbing. It’s clear that the Border Patrol failed to properly consider Mr. Shah Alam’s vulnerabilities and ensure his safe release. This incident highlights the need for major improvements in detainee care and release protocols.
I agree, the Border Patrol’s actions seem to have been seriously negligent. Releasing a visually impaired individual alone at a closed business is unacceptable. Reforms are clearly needed to prevent such tragedies in the future.