Listen to the article
Turkey’s Proposed “Disinformation Law” Threatens to Silence Online Expression
Turkish lawmakers from the ruling coalition have proposed legislation that would severely restrict online news outlets and social media platforms, raising alarm among free speech advocates. The draft bill, submitted on May 27, contains 40 articles aimed at criminalizing what authorities deem as “disinformation” across digital spaces.
The legislation would impose prison sentences of up to three years for sharing information considered misleading about “the internal and external security of the country, public order and public health.” Penalties could increase by 50 percent if content is posted from anonymous accounts.
This legislative push comes amid Turkey’s accelerating authoritarian trajectory under President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan. Facing mounting pressure from a reinvigorated opposition, Erdoğan’s administration has already taken steps to politicize the judiciary and modified electoral laws to disadvantage rival parties. While parliamentary vote on the disinformation bill was postponed until the next legislative session following internal disagreements within the ruling party, free speech advocates remain deeply concerned.
The proposed law represents the latest chapter in Turkey’s deteriorating media environment. Under Erdoğan’s rule, more than 90 percent of the country’s media outlets have fallen under direct or indirect government control, ensuring consistently favorable coverage of the president and his policies. Independent media organizations struggle with limited funding and face persistent legal challenges.
The country’s press freedom record is already dismal. Approximately 100 journalists currently sit in Turkish prisons, largely through the partisan application of anti-terrorism laws. The International Press Institute documented 241 journalist prosecutions in 2021 alone. Reporters routinely face police assault during protests, verbal attacks from politicians, and harassment from pro-government groups.
As traditional media outlets came under government control, social media emerged as a vital alternative information source for Turkish citizens. However, even this digital realm has not escaped government interference. The Information and Communication Technologies Authority has blocked access to more than 400,000 websites, including a temporary ban on Wikipedia in 2017.
For years, Turkey has led global rankings in requests to remove content from platforms like Twitter and Facebook, with tens of thousands of YouTube videos also blocked. In July 2020, parliament passed legislation requiring social media platforms with over one million users to appoint legal representatives in Turkey and store user data within the country – measures designed to facilitate government demands for content removal.
The new disinformation bill would significantly strengthen these existing controls. Its deliberately vague wording grants prosecutors broad latitude to criminalize virtually any criticism of public authorities. The law could severely limit public debate on sensitive political issues like migration and the economic crisis, while making it easier for authorities to remove social media content and prosecute individuals for their views.
“This will inevitably create a climate of fear and lead to widespread self-censorship,” said a representative from a Turkish press freedom organization who requested anonymity due to safety concerns. “It also allows the government to manipulate state accreditation and advertising to reward compliant online news outlets.”
The bill faces strong opposition from rival political parties, journalist associations, and civil society groups. The postponement of the parliamentary vote suggests divisions even within Erdoğan’s Justice and Development Party (AKP) regarding specific provisions, providing opposition groups additional time to exploit these fractures and mobilize public opinion.
European policymakers are being urged to remain vigilant regarding Erdoğan’s ongoing efforts to silence dissent. Turkey currently ranks 149th out of 180 countries in the Reporters Without Borders 2022 World Press Freedom Index – a troubling position for a country that remains, at least nominally, a European Union accession candidate.
If enacted, the disinformation law would severely undermine the ability of opposition groups to challenge government policies ahead of the critical 2023 elections. While Erdoğan has recently gained renewed popularity in Western capitals following Russia’s invasion of Ukraine – with the EU maintaining cooperation with Turkey on security, energy, and migration – critics argue that such partnerships should not come at the expense of ignoring significant human rights violations and attacks on free expression.
Fact Checker
Verify the accuracy of this article using The Disinformation Commission analysis and real-time sources.
10 Comments
While the intent to curb misinformation is understandable, this law appears to go too far in restricting online speech in Turkey. Broad definitions of ‘disinformation’ can too easily be weaponized against independent media and dissenting voices. Hoping for more narrow, proportionate measures instead.
The details of this Turkish law raise red flags about its potential to stifle free speech and independent reporting. While tackling misinformation is important, the broad definitions and severe punishments suggest this is more about controlling the narrative than protecting the public. Concerning development.
This disinformation law in Turkey is concerning. While I understand the desire to limit the spread of misleading information, the broad and harsh nature of the proposed penalties seems more like a crackdown on free expression than a targeted response to the problem. Hoping lawmakers take a more measured approach.
Curious to see how this law plays out in practice. On the surface it’s aimed at combating false information, but the harsh penalties and vague criteria raise alarm bells about potential censorship. Interested to hear more from Turkish civil society groups on their concerns.
Concerning to see Turkey enacting such restrictive laws around online speech. Cracking down on ‘disinformation’ can often be a cover for silencing critical voices and independent media. Hope lawmakers there reconsider this legislation and protect freedom of expression.
This law sounds like a worrying move towards increased censorship in Turkey. Freedom of the press and online expression are essential for a healthy democracy. I hope the pushback from civil society groups can lead to revisions or the law being withdrawn entirely.
You’re right, this is a concerning development. Turkey has a history of using vague laws to target political opponents and critical voices. This law seems ripe for abuse and risks further eroding democratic freedoms.
Turkey’s move to criminalize ‘disinformation’ is a troubling development for press freedom and online discourse. Even with good intentions, such vague and sweeping laws often end up being abused to silence critical voices. Hope the international community pushes back on this concerning trend.
Agreed, this law seems ripe for abuse and misuse against independent media and political opposition. The harsh penalties and lack of clear definitions are particularly worrying. Turkey should focus on building trust through transparency, not censorship.
This proposed ‘disinformation law’ in Turkey is deeply concerning. Vague criteria, harsh penalties, and a history of cracking down on dissent – a perfect recipe for censorship, not a genuine effort to combat misinformation. I hope the Turkish government reconsiders this legislation and protects fundamental freedoms instead.