Listen to the article
Pakistani authorities have accused the Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) party of orchestrating sophisticated foreign-backed social media campaigns to spread propaganda, according to statements made by Minister of State for Interior Tallal Chaudhry on Monday.
During a press conference in Islamabad, Chaudhry alleged that PTI has hired foreign companies to run paid hashtags and social media trends that disseminate “selective narratives and propaganda” against national interests. He presented what he described as evidence obtained directly from X (formerly Twitter).
“The companies create fake accounts in the name of women and news agencies that are being operated from foreign countries,” Chaudhry told reporters, detailing an elaborate mechanism where these operations allegedly function outside Pakistan’s borders.
According to the minister, PTI secures these services through auctions and finances them via foreign funding. The hired firms then establish social media accounts operated from countries “considered our enemies,” with handlers who are “neither PTI members nor people from Pakistan.”
Chaudhry explained how these operations allegedly maintain secrecy through temporary communication channels. “A company made a WhatsApp group to share instructions for a trend and then deleted it to prevent the instructions from being traced to various accounts operated in different countries,” he said. This process reportedly repeats with new WhatsApp groups and different participants for subsequent campaigns.
The minister claimed the paid accounts can retweet messages between 50 and 500 times, with payments ranging from “Rs50, Rs100, 10 cents or 2 cents” per tweet. More alarmingly, Chaudhry alleged these same accounts also promote content related to designated terrorist organizations.
“The accounts which make trends [for PTI] also create trends about the activities of TTP, BLA, and pro-Israel groups,” he stated, referring to the Tehrik-i-Taliban Pakistan and the Balochistan Liberation Army, both designated terrorist organizations.
The allegations come amid Pakistan’s increasingly tense political environment following the imprisonment of former Prime Minister Imran Khan, who founded PTI. Social media has become a crucial battlefield for political narratives in Pakistan, where digital activism has gained significant momentum in recent years.
While the government claims to have substantial information about individuals involved in these operations, Chaudhry indicated they are not currently pursuing criminal cases. “We are cautioning them not to be part of trends that are against the country for monetary gains,” he said.
When questioned about the financial scale of these operations, Chaudhry claimed payments are made in dollars through PTI’s foreign funding channels. He emphasized that, based on government analysis, “Pakistanis are rarely involved in these trends.”
The minister acknowledged the challenges in addressing these issues, noting that social media platforms typically do not provide IP addresses or account holder details due to privacy laws. Nevertheless, he indicated the government has engaged with social media companies to take action against the accounts in question and plans to contact countries where these accounts originate.
PTI has reportedly denied these allegations, maintaining that their social media support is organic and represents genuine public sentiment. “No one wants to own it. They say it [the trends and hashtags] is organic and [real] people participate in it,” Chaudhry noted, while insisting the government has evidence to the contrary.
The controversy highlights the growing global concern about coordinated inauthentic behavior on social media platforms and its potential to influence political discourse. Chaudhry referenced similar challenges in other regions, noting that “Some countries in Europe ban or block social media platforms to protect their interests.”
As digital platforms continue to evolve as critical components of political communication in Pakistan, this confrontation between the government and opposition over social media practices signals intensifying scrutiny of online political activities.
Fact Checker
Verify the accuracy of this article using The Disinformation Commission analysis and real-time sources.
8 Comments
The use of fake accounts and coordinated hashtag campaigns to spread propaganda is a worrying trend. Pakistan should strengthen its regulations and monitoring of online political activity to protect its sovereignty.
While the specifics are still unclear, the broader issue of foreign-backed social media manipulation in domestic politics is a global challenge that requires vigilance and a firm response.
These claims of foreign-backed propaganda campaigns raise important questions about the integrity of Pakistan’s political process. Proper investigation and transparency are crucial to maintain public trust.
These are serious allegations that, if proven true, would undermine public trust in the political process. Transparent investigations and reform are needed to safeguard Pakistan’s democracy.
Utilizing foreign firms for domestic political messaging is a serious matter. I hope the relevant authorities conduct a thorough, impartial inquiry to get to the bottom of these allegations.
Interesting allegations about PTI’s social media tactics. If true, that’s concerning as it undermines transparent political discourse. I’d like to see more details on the evidence Chaudhry presented.
Social media manipulation by political parties is a growing global issue. Pakistan must ensure a level playing field and safeguard democratic institutions from undue foreign influence, if these claims are valid.
The use of foreign firms to run coordinated social media campaigns for political gain is a concerning trend globally. Pakistan must ensure its democratic institutions are protected from undue external influence.