Listen to the article
Derry Riot Could Have Been “Staged for Propaganda,” Court Hears in Lyra McKee Murder Trial
A riot in Derry’s Creggan area during which journalist Lyra McKee was fatally shot may have been orchestrated as “a staged show of force for propaganda purposes,” Belfast Crown Court heard Monday.
The proceedings, now in its final stages, involve nine men facing various charges related to the violent disturbances of April 18, 2019, when 29-year-old McKee was struck by a bullet fired at police vehicles during serious unrest.
Three defendants—Paul McIntyre (58) from Kells Walk, Jordan Devine (25) from Bishop Street, and Peter Cavanagh (37) from Mary Street—stand charged with McKee’s murder, though prosecutors do not allege they fired the fatal shot. Instead, the trio is accused on a joint enterprise basis of intentionally encouraging or assisting the gunman. All three have denied the charges.
The remaining defendants face charges including rioting and throwing petrol bombs. They are Christopher Gillen (45) from Balbane Pass, Joseph Campbell (25) from Gosheden Cottages, Patrick Gallagher (33) from John Field Place, Jude McCrory (28) from Gartan Square, Joseph Barr (37) from Sandringham Drive, and Kieran McCool (57) from Ballymagowan Gardens. A tenth defendant, William Elliot (58), passed away in England last February.
During Monday’s session of the non-jury trial, defense attorneys presented closing arguments that questioned the prosecution’s narrative. John Kearney KC, representing Peter Cavanagh, characterized the case against his client as “circumstantial” and challenged whether the prosecution had proven the gunman intended to kill or cause grievous bodily harm to police officers.
Kearney highlighted that no officer was outside their armored Land Rover when shots were fired in what he described as “a 30 second burst of shooting” and noted there was “no serious penetrative damage” to the police vehicles.
In a significant contextual argument, Kearney drew attention to the presence of television presenter Reggie Yates and an MTV crew in Derry throughout the day of the shooting. He suggested to Justice Smyth that the events in Creggan that evening were “consistent with a staged show of force, a show of strength, for propaganda purposes.”
“This activity was with an eye to publicity… that was the predominant purpose for the unfolding trouble generally,” Kearney argued, offering an alternative interpretation to the murder charge his client faces.
Prosecutors have identified Cavanagh as “Person G” in footage—an individual wearing a camouflage mask who allegedly played a “stewarding role” around the time of the gun attack. Kearney countered there was “no evidence” that Person G communicated with the crowd or had his hands raised in a directing manner.
Addressing forensic evidence linking Cavanagh to a burned item of clothing found near an abandoned hijacked car, Kearney proposed “entirely innocent” explanations, suggesting DNA transfer could have occurred “on some occasion over the preceding days, weeks or months” through touching, coughing, or sneezing.
The court also heard from Ciaran Mallon KC, defending Christopher Gillen, who faces charges related to petrol bombs on both April 16 and 18, as well as the theft and burning of a Ford Transit tipper truck on April 18.
Mallon challenged the identification of his client as the masked “Person L” in footage, stating the case was “based exclusively on clothing identification.” He pointed out discrepancies between clothing worn by Person L and descriptions of those who stole the truck, adding that searches of Gillen’s home failed to recover the Trespass jacket and blue Nike trainers prosecutors claim link him to the scene.
The trial has drawn significant attention across Northern Ireland as it examines the events surrounding McKee’s death, which shocked the journalism community and the wider public. Her killing came during a period of heightened tensions in Derry, occurring just days before the Easter weekend, traditionally a sensitive time in Northern Ireland.
Defense submissions are expected to continue Tuesday as the long-running trial approaches its conclusion.
Fact Checker
Verify the accuracy of this article using The Disinformation Commission analysis and real-time sources.
9 Comments
Staging a riot for propaganda would be a shocking abuse of power. I hope the trial provides clarity on the real motives and circumstances surrounding Lyra McKee’s death. Her family and the public deserve the full truth, no matter how uncomfortable it may be.
Wow, the possibility of this being staged for propaganda is quite alarming. I’ll be following the trial closely to understand the facts. Regardless of the intent, the loss of Lyra McKee’s life is a tragedy that demands justice.
This is a complex and troubling case. The potential for propaganda is worrying, but the priority should be getting to the bottom of what happened and holding the responsible parties accountable. Lyra McKee’s life was cut short tragically, and her memory deserves justice.
This is a disturbing revelation. Using violence and tragedy for political gain is unacceptable. I’ll be following the trial closely to see if the evidence supports the claims of propaganda. Lyra McKee deserves justice, and the truth must come out.
It’s good the authorities are investigating this thoroughly. Staging riots for propaganda would be a serious abuse. I hope the truth comes out, regardless of any political motives. Lyra McKee’s death was a tragedy, and justice needs to be served.
This seems like a complex and nuanced case. I’m curious to hear more details about the potential propaganda angle – it would be concerning if the riot was staged for political purposes. Hopefully the trial provides a clear picture of what actually occurred that tragic night.
If the riot was indeed orchestrated for propaganda purposes, that’s a very serious abuse. The truth needs to come out, even if it’s politically inconvenient. Lyra McKee and her family deserve nothing less than a full and impartial investigation.
The idea that this riot could have been staged is deeply concerning. Propaganda has no place in criminal investigations. I sincerely hope the trial gets to the bottom of what truly happened and ensures justice is served for Lyra McKee.
This is a disturbing development. Using violence and unrest as propaganda is completely unacceptable. The motives behind the riot need to be fully examined. My condolences to Lyra McKee’s family – they deserve answers and accountability.