Listen to the article
President Trump’s immigration claims during a Thanksgiving military call have sparked immediate backlash from Fox News viewers, who criticized his statements about the situation at the southern border.
During a video call with U.S. military personnel on Thanksgiving Day from his Mar-a-Lago resort in Florida, President Trump praised the 101st Airborne Division for their work at the U.S.-Mexico border. However, his comments about immigration numbers drew scrutiny when he claimed, “We have nobody coming in. They’re not coming in. Under Biden, they were coming in by the millions.” He doubled down on this assertion, adding, “Now we have nobody coming in. We have a strong border. Nobody talks about it anymore.”
These statements prompted swift reactions on social media, with viewers questioning the accuracy of the President’s claims. One viewer wrote on X, “Aye, maybe more like ‘nobody’ in your dreams, love. Can’t think of a less convincing way to spin the reality down that border!” Another pointed out the nuance of the situation: “Neither ‘millions coming in’ nor ‘nobody coming in’ is accurate. The truth is always more nuanced.”
Immigration statistics and border security have been contentious issues throughout both the Biden and Trump administrations. While there was indeed a significant surge in border crossings during portions of the Biden presidency, with monthly encounters regularly exceeding 200,000 at certain points, the characterization of “nobody” crossing under the current administration contradicts official border patrol data.
The debate over immigration numbers extends beyond the President’s recent comments. Stephen Miller, the White House’s deputy chief of staff for policy, made a similar claim on Fox News just a day earlier, stating that the administration would “accelerate efforts to review every single person added to this country over the last four years, all 20 million.”
Immigration experts have challenged these figures. The Pew Research Center, which regularly analyzes immigration patterns, estimates the total undocumented population in the United States at approximately 11 to 13 million people. This estimate has remained relatively stable over many years, though it has seen fluctuations.
Alex Nowrasteh, Senior Vice President for Policy at the Cato Institute, a libertarian think tank that regularly analyzes immigration data, addressed these claims directly. “Vice President JD Vance and a collection of online conservative commentators have argued that, as president, Joe Biden let in 20 or 30 million illegal immigrants, swelling their population to 30-50 million,” Nowrasteh wrote. “These numbers are an exaggeration, but there was a large increase in the illegal immigrant population during the Biden administration.”
Border security remains one of the most divisive policy areas in American politics. The Biden administration has faced criticism for record-high border encounters during portions of his term, while Trump continues to highlight border security as a signature policy achievement of his administration.
Immigration experts point out that border dynamics are complex, influenced by factors including global migration patterns, economic conditions in Central and South America, climate change impacts, and the effectiveness of various enforcement strategies. The polarized rhetoric from both sides of the political spectrum often simplifies these complexities into absolute terms that don’t fully capture the reality at the border.
As the administration continues to emphasize its border policies, fact-checkers and immigration experts will likely continue scrutinizing claims about immigration numbers from officials on both sides of the political divide, highlighting the importance of accurate data in public discourse about one of America’s most consequential policy debates.
Fact Checker
Verify the accuracy of this article using The Disinformation Commission analysis and real-time sources.
12 Comments
The President’s statements about ‘nobody coming in’ seem quite at odds with the immigration statistics and border security data. While border crossings may have decreased from previous highs, claiming ‘nobody’ is entering is clearly an exaggeration.
Exactly, the truth is rarely black and white when it comes to complex issues like immigration. Leaders should strive for nuance and accuracy, not inflammatory rhetoric.
It’s unfortunate to see the President making false claims that are so easily disproven. Responsible governance requires acknowledging the full picture, not cherry-picking data to fit a narrative. Fact-based discourse is essential for addressing these important issues.
I agree, we should expect more from our elected leaders. Providing misleading information, even on complex topics, undermines public trust and constructive policymaking.
The President’s statements about immigration seem to bear little resemblance to the actual data and statistics. Claiming ‘millions’ were entering under the previous administration, or that ‘nobody’ is entering now, is simply not supported by the facts. Responsible leadership requires acknowledging the nuances of complex issues, not pushing demonstrably false narratives.
Well said. Fact-based discussions, even on contentious topics, are essential for good governance. Resorting to hyperbole and misinformation only serves to further divide and distract from finding real solutions.
It’s concerning to see the President making sweeping claims about immigration that appear to be disconnected from reality. While border crossings may have shifted, painting an absolutist picture of ‘nobody’ entering is clearly an oversimplification. Responsible leadership requires grappling with the full complexity of the situation.
I agree, the President’s comments undermine efforts to have a meaningful, evidence-based dialogue about immigration policy. Factual accuracy should be the foundation for any meaningful discussion on this issue.
The President’s statements about ‘millions’ of people entering under the previous administration and ‘nobody’ entering now seem like gross exaggerations not supported by the data. We need honest, fact-based dialogue to tackle immigration challenges, not hyperbolic rhetoric.
Absolutely. Nuance and objectivity are critical when discussing sensitive issues like immigration. Resorting to inflammatory falsehoods is counterproductive and erodes public confidence.
It’s concerning to see the President making such inaccurate claims about immigration. The facts show a much more nuanced situation at the border. Responsible leadership requires acknowledging the complexities rather than oversimplifying or spreading misinformation.
I agree, it’s important for public figures to provide honest and fact-based assessments, even if the reality is more complex than simple sound bites.