Listen to the article
In a case of mistaken identity amid a national tragedy, several media outlets and social media users have circulated incorrect images while reporting on the fatal plane crash that claimed the life of Nationalist Congress Party leader Ajit Pawar and four others in Maharashtra’s Baramati on Wednesday.
The private aircraft carrying Pawar crashed while attempting to land, killing all five occupants on board—Pawar, his Personal Security Officer Vidip Jadhav, pilots Captain Sumit Kapoor and Captain Shambhavi Pathak, and flight attendant Pinky Mali.
As news of the tragedy spread across social media platforms, numerous posts began sharing tributes to the victims, including photos purportedly showing Captain Sumit Kapoor, one of the pilots who perished in the crash. Several reputable news organizations, including The Quint, published these images as part of their coverage.
However, an investigation by India Today’s fact-checking team has revealed that the widely circulated photo does not depict Captain Kapoor at all, but rather shows Captain Sahil Madaan, another pilot who was not involved in the incident.
The confusion appears to have originated when certain media outlets incorrectly identified the man in the photograph. A reverse image search led to Captain Madaan’s LinkedIn profile, which features the exact same image being shared in the viral posts.
Adding to the confusion, news outlet DNA shared an Instagram post that wrongly identified the deceased pilot as Sahil Madaan while using Madaan’s photograph. The error became apparent when a user named Sanjam Sahni commented on the post stating: “Please remove this news. Capt. Sahil Madaan is my husband and he was not in that aircraft. Please get your facts correct.”
Sahni, identified as a makeup artist on her profile, later addressed the situation in her Instagram Stories, writing: “Last 24 hours have been very heavy on our family. My condolences to the families who are victims of an ill-fated flight. But for all those concerned for Capt. Sahil Madaan. He is fine. He was not on the flight. The publishers have published his name with his photos by mistake.”
According to official reports, Captain Sumit Kapoor was the pilot-in-command of the Learjet 45 aircraft, with Captain Shambhavi Pathak serving as co-pilot. Both were highly experienced aviation professionals based in Delhi.
VK Singh, a senior official at VSR Aviation, the company that operated the flight, confirmed to India Today that Captain Kapoor had accumulated over 16,000 hours of flying experience throughout his career, having previously worked with airlines including Sahara, Jetline, and Jet Airways. The co-pilot, Captain Pathak, had logged approximately 1,500 flight hours.
Interestingly, Captain Sahil Madaan, whose photo has been mistakenly circulated, is also employed by VSR Aviation, according to his LinkedIn profile. This connection may have contributed to the confusion in initial reporting.
The incident highlights the challenges of accurate reporting in the digital age, where misinformation can spread rapidly during breaking news events. It also underscores the importance of thorough fact-checking by both media organizations and social media users, particularly when reporting on tragic events affecting multiple families.
As investigations into the crash continue, authorities have yet to release official statements regarding the cause of the accident that claimed the lives of the prominent political leader and four others.
Fact Checker
Verify the accuracy of this article using The Disinformation Commission analysis and real-time sources.
14 Comments
The plane crash in Baramati is a devastating loss. My sincere condolences to the families of those who perished. The incorrect identification of the pilot is a concerning mistake that must be addressed.
You’re absolutely right. Journalists have a responsibility to verify facts, especially when reporting on tragedies like this. This error should not have occurred.
The plane crash in Baramati is a terrible tragedy. My condolences to the families of those who lost their lives. The misidentification of the pilot is a concerning error that must be addressed.
You’re right, this is a serious mistake that should not have happened. Fact-checking is essential, especially when reporting on sensitive events like this.
Tragic news about the plane crash in Baramati. My condolences to the families of those who perished. It’s concerning to see the mix-up around the pilot’s identity, highlighting the need for careful fact-checking in such sensitive situations.
Yes, it’s important to get the facts right, especially when reporting on a tragic incident like this. Misidentifying the pilot is an unfortunate error that should be corrected.
This is a heartbreaking incident, and my thoughts go out to the families of the victims. The misidentification of the pilot is concerning and highlights the need for thorough fact-checking in journalism.
Absolutely. Accurate reporting is crucial, especially when covering tragedies like this. I hope the investigators can provide a clear picture of what happened.
This is a deeply saddening incident, and my heart goes out to the victims’ loved ones. The mix-up around the pilot’s identity is troubling and highlights the need for rigorous verification of information in journalism.
I agree, the misidentification is an unfortunate error that should be corrected. Accurate reporting is crucial, especially when covering such a tragic event.
This is a sobering reminder of the risks associated with air travel. My heart goes out to the victims’ loved ones. I hope the investigation into the crash can provide answers and prevent similar incidents in the future.
Agreed. Proper identification of the victims is crucial for honoring their memory and providing closure to their families.
It’s a shame to see the incorrect identification of the pilot in this tragedy. Reliable reporting is essential, especially when covering such a sensitive event. My sympathies to all those affected by this terrible accident.
You’re right, the media has a responsibility to verify facts before publishing, especially in cases involving loss of life. This mistake is regrettable.