Listen to the article
School Tragedy in Maharashtra: 13-Year-Old Dies Following Alleged Corporal Punishment
Controversy has erupted in Maharashtra’s Vasai district after a 13-year-old girl reportedly died following corporal punishment administered at her school. The Class VI student, identified as Anshika Gaud (also referred to as Kajal Gaud in some reports), was allegedly forced to perform 100 sit-ups as punishment for arriving late to school on November 8.
According to local sources, Anshika, who suffered from a pre-existing medical condition, experienced breathing difficulties later that day and required hospitalization. Her condition deteriorated over the following days, and she passed away on November 14, nearly a week after the incident.
The case has sparked outrage across social media platforms, with many condemning the use of physical punishment in educational institutions. However, misinformation has also begun circulating online, with unrelated footage being falsely linked to Anshika’s death.
A viral video showing a schoolgirl collapsing onto a bench in a school corridor has been widely shared with claims that it depicts an “8-year-old who died due to cardiac arrest after 100 sit-ups punishment.” Fact-checking by India Today has revealed that this footage is entirely unrelated to the Vasai incident.
Through reverse image searches and verification with regional journalists, investigators determined that the video actually shows eight-year-old Gargi Ranpara, who suffered a cardiac arrest at Zebar School for Children in Ahmedabad’s Thaltej area on January 10 of this year.
Sharmistha Sinha, the principal of Zebar School, had stated at the time, “The girl had no prior health issues. Doctors informed us that Gargi had suffered a cardiac arrest. They attempted to revive her and placed her on ventilator support, but unfortunately, she did not survive.”
Atul Tiwari, an Ahmedabad-based correspondent who covered Gargi’s story, confirmed that her collapse was unrelated to any form of punishment. “On the morning of January 10, Gargi Ranpara climbed the stairs to school and suffered a cardiac arrest. This incident is unrelated to the 100 sit-ups or any other punishment administered by school teachers,” Tiwari stated.
The Ahmedabad incident had prompted a police investigation, with Bodakdev police inspector Apurva Patel registering it as an accidental death at the time.
Meanwhile, authorities in Maharashtra are investigating Anshika Gaud’s death, focusing on the allegations of excessive corporal punishment. The case has reignited debates about disciplinary practices in Indian schools and the enforcement of existing regulations against physical punishment.
Corporal punishment has been officially banned in Indian schools under the Right to Education Act of 2009, which prohibits physical and mental harassment of students. Despite this legislation, reports of such incidents continue to surface periodically across the country.
Child rights advocates have seized on this latest tragedy to call for stricter implementation of anti-corporal punishment laws and better monitoring systems within educational institutions. Many have pointed to the need for alternative disciplinary approaches that don’t endanger students’ physical or emotional wellbeing.
Educational experts emphasize that the incident highlights the urgent need for comprehensive teacher training on appropriate disciplinary measures and greater awareness of the potential consequences of corporal punishment, particularly for children with underlying health conditions.
As the investigation into Anshika’s death continues, her family and community await answers regarding the circumstances that led to this tragedy. The case serves as a sobering reminder of the potential fatal consequences of disciplinary practices that violate children’s rights and safety in educational settings.
Local education authorities have not yet issued an official statement regarding the specific actions being taken against the school or staff members allegedly involved in the incident.
Fact Checker
Verify the accuracy of this article using The Disinformation Commission analysis and real-time sources.
9 Comments
Punishing students with physically demanding exercises like 100 sit-ups is completely unacceptable, especially for those with health issues. Schools need to rethink their disciplinary approaches to focus on positive reinforcement, not harm.
Tragic incident. Schools should never resort to corporal punishment, especially for students with health issues. Hope the authorities investigate this thoroughly and take appropriate actions to prevent such incidents in the future.
Agreed. Corporal punishment is unacceptable and can have serious consequences, especially for vulnerable students. Schools need better disciplinary policies focused on rehabilitation, not harm.
Misinformation around tragic events like this is so harmful. I’m glad the fact-check article was able to clarify that the viral video was unrelated. Accurate reporting is crucial in cases like this.
Yes, spreading false information can distract from the real issue and undermine efforts to seek justice and accountability. Fact-checking is an important service to combat the spread of misinformation.
This is very concerning. Forcing a student with a pre-existing condition to do 100 sit-ups as punishment seems extremely reckless and dangerous. My condolences to the family.
Absolutely. Schools have a duty of care to protect their students, not put them at risk of harm. Reforms are clearly needed to ensure the safety and wellbeing of all students.
This is a devastating story. My heart goes out to Anshika’s family. No child should die due to excessive punishment at school. I hope the authorities take strong action to prevent such tragedies in the future.
Agreed. Schools need to have clear, humane disciplinary policies that prioritize student welfare. Corporal punishment should be banned, and teachers must be properly trained in alternative, non-violent methods.