Listen to the article
U.S. Sen. Jim Justice of West Virginia has agreed to pay nearly $5.2 million in overdue personal taxes, adding another chapter to the former billionaire’s long history of financial difficulties.
The settlement came Monday when Justice and his wife, Cathy, entered into a joint motion for consent judgment with the federal government. The agreement was signed the same day the government filed a lawsuit claiming the couple had “neglected or refused to make full payment” for income taxes dating back to 2009.
Justice, who previously served as West Virginia’s governor for two terms, has seen his financial empire crumble dramatically in recent years. Forbes magazine once estimated his fortune at $1.9 billion, but stripped him of his billionaire status in 2021 when his worth fell to approximately $513 million. Earlier this year, Forbes assessed that Justice’s net worth had deteriorated to “less than zero,” with his liabilities far exceeding his assets.
The tax settlement is merely the latest in a series of financial challenges for Justice, who was elected to the Senate last November, taking the seat vacated by retiring Sen. Joe Manchin. Justice owns dozens of businesses spanning coal mining, agriculture, and hospitality sectors, including the historic Greenbrier Resort.
Just last month, the Internal Revenue Service filed liens totaling more than $8 million against Justice and his wife for unpaid personal taxes. In September, West Virginia tax officials filed $1.4 million in liens against The Greenbrier and the resort’s Greenbrier Sporting Club over unpaid sales taxes.
Other financial troubles have mounted. A foreclosure auction targeting several hundred lots owned by the Justice family at a resort community near Beckley was recently paused pending review by the state Supreme Court. The dispute involves unpaid fees between the Glade Springs Village Property Owners Association and Justice Holdings.
The Greenbrier itself, a 710-room luxury hotel that has hosted U.S. presidents, royalty, and congressional retreats, narrowly avoided foreclosure last year. The property came under threat of being auctioned after JPMorgan Chase sold a longstanding loan to Beltway Capital, which declared it to be in default. The Justice family eventually settled these debts to retain ownership of the iconic property.
The West Virginia Democratic Party has criticized Justice, describing the financial struggles as “a direct consequence of his own financial incompetence.”
Labor issues have also plagued Justice’s businesses. A union official at The Greenbrier reported last year that Justice’s family was approximately $2.4 million behind in payments to an employees’ health insurance fund, jeopardizing workers’ coverage. Additionally, dozens of properties owned by the Justice family were auctioned in 2023 to pay delinquent real estate taxes.
Justice’s coal mining operations have faced legal challenges as well, with various entities attempting to recover millions in fines for environmental violations and unsafe working conditions.
When questioned about his financial issues during a media briefing in October, Justice defended himself, stating that his companies “are complicated and complex” and that his children “are doing a magnificent job” running them. He suggested that collection efforts against him were politically motivated, saying, “At the end of the day, I’d say just let it be and see how it all plays out.”
Justice purchased The Greenbrier resort out of bankruptcy in 2009 for $20.1 million. The historic property, which dates back to 1778, features a casino, spa, and numerous amenities, employing around 2,000 workers. The resort hosted a PGA Tour golf tournament for nearly a decade and has welcomed NFL teams for training camps. It also contains a once-secret 112,000-square-foot underground bunker, built during the Cold War as a potential shelter for Congress in case of nuclear attack.
A spokesperson for Justice’s office did not immediately respond to requests for comment on the tax settlement.
Fact Checker
Verify the accuracy of this article using The Disinformation Commission analysis and real-time sources.
12 Comments
While I appreciate the Senator taking responsibility for the overdue taxes, it’s concerning to see such a large unpaid tax bill. This highlights the importance of elected officials maintaining sound financial practices and transparency. I hope this serves as a wake-up call for greater accountability.
Agreed, elected officials must be held to high standards when it comes to their personal finances. Transparency and accountability are crucial for maintaining public trust.
This seems like a complicated situation. I’m curious to learn more about the financial challenges Senator Justice has faced and how this tax settlement impacts his businesses and political career. It will be interesting to see how this plays out going forward.
You’re right, the financial troubles for Senator Justice appear to be significant. It will be worth following this story to understand the full scope and implications.
The downfall of Senator Justice’s financial empire is quite remarkable, going from billionaire status to reportedly having a net worth of less than zero. This tax settlement is just the latest chapter in what seems to be a complex and troubling situation. I hope he is able to turn things around, but it will require significant effort.
Absolutely, the steep decline in his net worth is striking. It will be important to follow how he manages to address these financial challenges and whether it impacts his political career going forward.
While it’s commendable that Senator Justice is taking responsibility for the overdue taxes, the sheer size of the settlement is concerning. This highlights the importance of elected officials maintaining sound financial practices and transparency. I hope this serves as a wake-up call for greater accountability and oversight, not just for Justice but for all public officials.
I agree, this situation underscores the need for heightened financial scrutiny and accountability for our elected representatives. The public deserves leaders who demonstrate responsible financial management and transparency.
This tax settlement is just the tip of the iceberg when it comes to Senator Justice’s financial troubles. The fact that he was once a billionaire but has now fallen so far is quite remarkable. I’m curious to see how he plans to stabilize his businesses and personal finances, and whether this will affect his ability to effectively serve in the Senate.
You raise a good point. The scale of Justice’s financial decline is quite staggering. It will be interesting to see how he navigates these challenges and whether it impacts his political standing and decision-making.
This is a significant tax settlement for Senator Justice. I’m curious to know more about the reasons behind the overdue payments and how he plans to address the broader financial challenges facing his businesses and political standing. It’s an important issue to watch closely.
You raise a good point. The details around the tax issues and Justice’s financial troubles will be crucial for understanding the full context and implications of this story.