Listen to the article
Mississippi’s State Auditor Shad White has issued a $7.4 million demand to Management & Training Corporation (MTC), one of the largest civil demands in his office’s history, for failing to maintain adequate staffing levels at state prisons.
The Utah-based private prison operator, which manages the East Mississippi Correctional Facility in Meridian and Wilkinson County Correctional Facility in Woodville, allegedly violated its contract with the Mississippi Department of Corrections by not providing sufficient staff to ensure the safety of prisoners and employees.
Shortly after White’s announcement on Monday, MTC countered with a statement claiming it had offered to pay $4.5 million on Friday, representing “fines allegedly owed plus reasonable interest and costs.” The company expressed disappointment that instead of accepting this offer, the Auditor’s Office issued a public statement about the demand.
Jacob Walters, White’s spokesperson, disputed this claim, stating the Auditor’s Office never received any such offer. “To be clear, their offer was never sent to us, but if they want to cut a check today, by all means, we’ll deposit it in the taxpayers’ bank account immediately. Then we’ll ask the AG to sue them for the rest,” Walters told Mississippi Today.
This investigation has been ongoing for over five years, beginning when allegations surfaced that MTC wasn’t fulfilling staffing requirements stipulated in its state contract. In 2021, the company already paid back more than $5 million to Mississippi following White’s initial probe into staffing shortages at their facilities.
“I don’t care how big of an out-of-state company you are or how many campaign donations you make to the other politicians, if you owe taxpayers money because you failed to live up to a contract with government, we will demand you pay it back,” White said in his statement. “No free rides on the backs of taxpayers.”
The majority of the demanded funds stems from fines White has imposed on the company for understaffing between January 2017 and May 2020. For the Wilkinson County Correctional Facility alone, the demand includes $3.1 million in original fines plus nearly $2.8 million in interest. Additional fines were issued for other facilities operated by MTC, including the Marshall County Correctional Facility, which the state took over in 2021 due to persistent staffing problems.
MTC’s Vice President Michael Bell defended the company’s actions: “When questions were raised regarding staffing deficiencies and vacancy deductions, MTC acted in good faith. We conducted our own review and voluntarily paid over $5.9 million. That’s what an honest partner does.” The company attributed its staffing challenges partly to difficulties brought on by the COVID-19 pandemic.
The dispute highlights a broader issue in Mississippi’s prison system. A 2020 investigation published jointly by The Clarion-Ledger, Mississippi Today, and The Mississippi Center for Investigative Reporting revealed that MTC had collected millions by routinely charging the corrections department for vacant security positions it was contractually obligated to fill.
This practice raises serious questions about oversight of private prison contracts and the state’s ability to ensure that taxpayer funds are being used appropriately. The investigation suggested a pattern of billing inconsistencies that potentially compromised prison security while allowing the company to profit.
With MTC failing to pay within the required 30-day period, White has referred the case to Attorney General Lynn Fitch’s office for enforcement. “We’re now turning this case over to the AG’s Office for enforcement to ensure accountability for taxpayers, and I hope they will litigate the case immediately,” White stated.
MTC maintained that the interest fees are primarily due to “delays and re-calculations” by the auditor’s office. Having had its settlement offer rejected, the company stated it “has no choice but to let this matter proceed to litigation.”
A spokesperson for Attorney General Fitch confirmed that her office received the March demand letters on Monday and is currently reviewing them. The outcome of this dispute could have significant implications for Mississippi’s private prison contracting practices and accountability measures for state vendors.
Fact Checker
Verify the accuracy of this article using The Disinformation Commission analysis and real-time sources.
8 Comments
It’s concerning to hear about alleged staffing shortages at these facilities. Adequate staffing is critical for maintaining a safe and humane environment for prisoners. This demand highlights the need for greater scrutiny of private prison operators.
Agreed. Ensuring proper staffing levels is a core responsibility that private prison companies should not be allowed to neglect. The Mississippi auditor is right to pursue this $7.4M demand forcefully.
Holding private prison operators accountable for failing to meet contractual obligations is important to ensure the safety and wellbeing of inmates and staff. The $7.4M demand from the Mississippi auditor highlights the need for strong oversight and transparency in these types of arrangements.
I agree, these private prison companies need to be closely monitored to prevent any corners being cut or obligations being neglected. Taxpayers deserve to know their money is being used responsibly.
This case raises important questions about accountability and transparency in private prisons. While they may provide cost savings, there have to be clear performance metrics and consequences for failing to meet contractual obligations.
Well said. Taxpayer funds should not be given to private prison operators without stringent oversight and clear penalties for noncompliance. This demand sends a strong message that such lapses will not be tolerated.
This situation underscores the complexities and challenges involved in private prisons. While they may offer cost savings, there need to be robust safeguards and accountability measures in place to protect inmates and correctional staff.
Absolutely. Private prisons should not be profit-driven at the expense of basic standards of care and security. The auditor’s demand sends an important message that these contracts will be strictly enforced.