Listen to the article
New York City’s mayor-elect Zohran Mamdani has reaffirmed his stance that he would honor the International Criminal Court’s arrest warrant for Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu if the leader visits the city, setting the stage for a potential diplomatic confrontation when he takes office in January.
The comments came as outgoing Mayor Eric Adams met with Netanyahu and reportedly encouraged the Israeli leader to attend Mamdani’s upcoming inauguration as a show of support for New York’s Jewish community, according to Israeli media outlet Israel Hayom.
“I’ve said time and again that I believe this is a city of international law, and being a city of international law means looking to uphold international law,” Mamdani said during a recent appearance on ABC7. “And that means upholding the warrants from the International Criminal Court, whether they’re for Benjamin Netanyahu or Vladimir Putin.”
The ICC issued arrest warrants for Netanyahu and former Israeli Defense Minister Yoav Gallant in November 2024, accusing them of crimes against humanity including intentionally attacking civilians and using starvation as a method of warfare during the Gaza conflict.
This position isn’t new for Mamdani, who expressed similar sentiments during his campaign. In an October interview with Fox News’ Martha MacCallum, he stated he would arrest Netanyahu if legally permitted, emphasizing that New York “wants to uplift and uphold” such principles.
Mamdani, who will become the first Muslim and South Asian mayor of New York City when he takes office on January 1, has clarified that he wouldn’t create new laws to facilitate an arrest but would “exhaust every legal possibility” within existing frameworks.
“Unlike Donald Trump, I’m someone who looks to exist within the confines of the laws that we have,” he said. “So I will look to exhaust every legal possibility, not create my own laws, to do so.”
Legal experts point out significant complications with Mamdani’s position. The United States is not a signatory to the Rome Statute that established the ICC, raising questions about the legal authority to enforce an ICC warrant on American soil. Additionally, foreign heads of state typically enjoy diplomatic immunity under international law when on official visits.
The situation creates a complex diplomatic and legal challenge that could affect U.S.-Israel relations, which are already navigating transitions with the Trump administration’s return to the White House in January.
Outgoing Mayor Adams, who has maintained strong ties with Israel during his tenure, appears to be deliberately creating a high-profile test for his successor by encouraging Netanyahu’s attendance at the January 1 inauguration.
“I believe the prime minister should visit the city. I think he should start with the inauguration ceremony of Mamdani in the presence of the City Council on January 1 to send a strong message to the largest Jewish community outside Israel,” Adams told Israel Hayom. “He needs to make clear to the entire community that he will continue visiting the city as often as possible, and he should begin on January 1.”
The showdown over Netanyahu’s potential visit represents the first major international policy challenge for Mamdani, who has positioned himself as a progressive focused on both local and global justice issues. His election in November was seen as a significant shift leftward for New York City politics.
Despite his position on the ICC warrants, Mamdani has emphasized his commitment to protecting New York’s Jewish community, which numbers approximately 1.6 million people and is the largest Jewish population outside of Israel.
“It will be my responsibility that I will uphold to not only protect Jewish New Yorkers, but to celebrate and cherish them in the city,” he stated during his ABC7 interview.
The Biden administration has previously rejected the ICC’s decision to issue arrest warrants for Israeli officials, with the State Department calling the move “deeply disappointing.” The incoming Trump administration is expected to take an even stronger stance against ICC actions targeting Israeli officials.
The White House has not yet commented on Mamdani’s renewed statements regarding Netanyahu.
Fact Checker
Verify the accuracy of this article using The Disinformation Commission analysis and real-time sources.
10 Comments
It’s interesting to see a local politician take such a strong stance on a major international issue. The arrest warrant for Netanyahu does raise complex questions around national sovereignty and international jurisdiction.
Indeed, this issue highlights the tension between national interests and the growing role of international institutions like the ICC. It will be fascinating to see how this plays out.
While I respect the mayor-elect’s commitment to international law, I’m concerned that this could become a political flashpoint and distract from more pressing local issues. Balancing global and local priorities will be key.
That’s a valid point. The mayor-elect will need to ensure that this high-profile issue doesn’t overshadow the day-to-day needs of New Yorkers. Careful management of priorities will be critical.
This is a controversial move by the mayor-elect that could have significant geopolitical implications. While upholding international law is important, the diplomatic fallout from arresting a sitting PM could be severe.
Agreed, this is a delicate situation that requires careful consideration of all factors. The mayor-elect will need to balance principles with pragmatic concerns.
While I appreciate the mayor-elect’s commitment to upholding international law, I’m concerned that this could jeopardize important diplomatic relationships and economic ties. These considerations shouldn’t be overlooked.
That’s a fair point. The mayor-elect will need to weigh the potential benefits and risks very carefully. Maintaining stability and prosperity for New Yorkers should also be a top priority.
This is a bold and principled stance, but the practical implications could be very messy. I hope the mayor-elect has thoroughly considered the potential fallout, both domestically and internationally.
Agreed. Enforcing an ICC warrant against a sitting PM is highly unusual and could set a precedent with far-reaching consequences. The mayor-elect will need to navigate this very carefully.