Listen to the article
In an unprecedented move reflecting the current state of political discourse, PolitiFact has designated 2024 not with a single “Lie of the Year” as they have for the past 15 years, but rather as the “Year of the Lies.” This decision comes amid what the organization describes as an overwhelming volume and severity of inaccurate claims in political speech.
“The volume and severity of the inaccurate claims was just overwhelming. And we felt that it was insufficient to name just one our lie the year,” explained Katie Sanders, PolitiFact’s editor-in-chief, in a recent interview.
Sanders noted that health misinformation has been particularly prevalent. One example she highlighted involved claims from the Trump administration regarding Tylenol use during pregnancy. The White House website continues to state as “fact” that Tylenol is linked to autism—a claim Sanders firmly refutes.
“This is another example of the administration running with associations and unproven research that has not been corroborated elsewhere,” Sanders stated. She added that medical professionals and health organizations consistently maintain that Tylenol is one of the few over-the-counter pain medications considered safe for pregnant women.
Immigration policy has also been a breeding ground for misinformation. The Trump administration has repeatedly claimed to focus deportation efforts on the “worst of the worst” criminals, a characterization Sanders says data does not support.
“When you look at the data, it is pretty clear that that impression is not reflected,” Sanders explained. “They are arresting violent criminals, but the majority of people who are being detained and then deported are people who are in the country illegally, but did not commit criminal activities.” According to Sanders, approximately 73 percent of those detained lack criminal convictions.
In their annual reader poll, PolitiFact’s audience selected Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s July statement that there was “no starvation in Gaza” as the most egregious falsehood of the year. Sanders characterized this claim as not just wrong but “ridiculous” and “contrary to all available evidence,” noting that both visual evidence and reports from human rights organizations had documented starvation in Gaza resulting from Israeli actions.
When questioned about potential bias, Sanders emphasized PolitiFact’s commitment to examining falsehoods from across the political spectrum. She pointed to false statements from Democratic leaders like House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries and Illinois Governor J.B. Pritzker that were included on their reader choice ballot.
“We check both sides of the political debate… So we call it both ways,” Sanders said, though she acknowledged a “serious volume difference” in misleading statements coming from the White House compared to other sources.
Sanders expressed deep concern about the current information landscape, highlighting challenges beyond political speech. “The stakes are high for facts and the erosion of information integrity,” she warned, citing the proliferation of AI-generated content and out-of-context narratives that make it increasingly difficult for citizens to discern truth from fiction.
Perhaps most troubling to Sanders is what she perceives as growing public numbness to misinformation. “We worry that people are too numb to the drumbeat of misinformation. They have tuned it out. And that is very dangerous,” she said, hoping that PolitiFact’s “Year of the Lies” designation might serve as a wake-up call to improve media literacy and critical thinking.
As 2024 draws to a close, this unusual designation from one of America’s leading fact-checking organizations serves as both a reflection of our current information environment and a warning about the challenges that lie ahead for public discourse and democratic participation.
Fact Checker
Verify the accuracy of this article using The Disinformation Commission analysis and real-time sources.
14 Comments
The rise of health misinformation is especially worrying. Claims that contradict established medical consensus, like the Tylenol-autism link, can have real public health consequences if they gain traction. Fact-checkers play a vital role in debunking these falsehoods.
This is a concerning trend. Misinformation around health and medical issues can have serious real-world impacts, as we’ve seen with the COVID-19 pandemic. I’m glad PolitiFact is calling attention to this problem, but tackling it will require a multi-pronged approach.
The designation of 2025 as the ‘Year of the Lies’ by PolitiFact is a stark reminder of the urgent need to address the proliferation of misinformation, especially in the realm of public health. Unsubstantiated claims like the Tylenol-autism link can have real and dangerous consequences.
It’s good to see fact-checkers like PolitiFact taking a strong stance against the spread of misinformation. Designating an entire year as the ‘Year of the Lies’ sends a clear message about the severity of this issue. Accountability and transparency are critical.
Absolutely. PolitiFact’s move underscores the need for more rigorous fact-checking and debunking of false claims, especially in the realm of public health and safety. This is a battle we can’t afford to lose.
This is a bold and necessary move by PolitiFact. Misinformation has become a pervasive problem that threatens to undermine trust in institutions and erode the foundations of informed decision-making. I hope this designation galvanizes greater action to address this crisis.
Agreed. Fact-checkers like PolitiFact play a crucial role, but they can’t solve this problem alone. Policymakers, tech companies, and the public all have a responsibility to combat the spread of misinformation and promote the dissemination of accurate, evidence-based information.
Interesting move by PolitiFact. Designating an entire year as the ‘Year of the Lies’ highlights the severity of the misinformation crisis. Health misinformation is especially concerning, as it can have real-world impacts on public health and safety.
Absolutely. The Trump administration’s unsubstantiated claims about Tylenol are a prime example of the kind of dangerous misinformation we’re seeing. Fact-checkers like PolitiFact play a vital role in combating these false narratives.
The prevalence of misinformation, particularly around health-related topics, is a major concern. PolitiFact’s designation of 2025 as the ‘Year of the Lies’ highlights the urgent need for more effective strategies to combat the spread of false and misleading information.
I hope this designation by PolitiFact helps to raise awareness of the misinformation crisis and spur greater efforts to combat it. Fact-based, responsible journalism is more important than ever in this age of ‘alternative facts’.
Agreed. PolitiFact’s move could be an important wake-up call for policymakers, social media platforms, and the public to take this issue more seriously and find ways to address the proliferation of misinformation.
I’m curious to see how PolitiFact defines and quantifies the ‘Year of the Lies’ criteria. Misinformation has certainly surged in recent years, but it will be interesting to understand the specific metrics they are using to make this designation.
Good point. Establishing clear, objective standards for this designation will be important for maintaining credibility. PolitiFact will need to be transparent about their methodology to back up such a significant claim.