Democratic Lawmakers Demand EAC Commissioner’s Resignation Over Voting Misinformation Claims

U.S. Senators Call for EAC Commissioner’s Resignation Over Noncitizen Voting Statements

A group of prominent U.S. Senators has issued a stern demand for Election Assistance Commission (EAC) Commissioner Christy McCormick to either retract statements regarding noncitizen voting or step down from her position, citing concerns over election integrity.

Senators Alex Padilla, Jeff Merkley, Adam Schiff, and Ron Wyden jointly criticized McCormick for comments made at a recent public event that they claim spread dangerous misinformation about the American electoral process. The lawmakers assert that McCormick’s rhetoric falsely connected noncitizens to Democratic Party voting strategies.

“These types of unfounded allegations directly undermine public trust in our democratic institutions,” said one of the senators in the joint statement. “Especially coming from an official whose role is to safeguard election integrity, such comments are particularly harmful.”

The senators emphasized in their letter that voting by noncitizens is both extremely rare and already illegal under federal law. They expressed concern that propagating such narratives without evidence contributes to a climate of suspicion that has real-world consequences, including increased threats against election workers and the justification of voter suppression measures.

This controversy emerges against a backdrop of ongoing national debate about election security. Senator Padilla, who previously served as California’s Secretary of State, has been particularly vocal on this issue. He has repeatedly condemned what he describes as systematic attempts to undermine voter access, notably criticizing former President Trump’s claims about election fraud.

The EAC, established by the Help America Vote Act of 2002, plays a crucial role in developing guidance to meet federal requirements for voting systems and addressing election administration issues. Commissioners like McCormick are expected to approach their duties with nonpartisan professionalism, which is why her alleged comments have drawn such sharp rebuke.

Election security experts note that the spreading of misinformation about noncitizen voting has become a persistent challenge in American politics. Despite multiple studies finding virtually no evidence of widespread noncitizen voting, the narrative continues to circulate, often amplified by public officials.

“When officials responsible for election oversight echo unfounded claims, it creates a dangerous feedback loop that can justify restrictive voting measures,” explained a voting rights advocate familiar with the situation. “These restrictions typically impact legitimate voters, particularly those from marginalized communities.”

Senator Padilla, who has taken a leading role in this effort, continues to be active on multiple legislative fronts. Recent financial disclosures show Padilla raised $287,600 in the third quarter of 2025, with over 95% coming from individual donors. The Senator reported $7.1 million in cash on hand, positioning him among the top 30 congressional members in terms of available campaign funds.

Beyond election security issues, Padilla remains engaged in diverse legislative initiatives. His recent proposals include the HOV Lane Exemption Reauthorization Act, America’s CHILDREN Act of 2025, and several land transfer acts benefiting Native American tribes in California, including the Pit River Land Transfer Act and the Shingle Springs Band of Miwok Indians Land Transfer Act.

The senators’ demand for McCormick’s correction or resignation highlights the increasingly contentious nature of election administration in America. With midterm elections approaching and the presidential election cycle not far behind, the integrity of electoral systems and the credibility of those who oversee them remain critical concerns for lawmakers on both sides of the aisle.

As of publication, Commissioner McCormick has not publicly responded to the senators’ demands. The EAC’s press office declined to comment when reached for a statement on the matter.