Listen to the article
La Habra Medical Provider to Pay Over $8.3 Million for Alleged Kickback Scheme
A La Habra-based provider of positron emission tomography (PET) scan services has agreed to pay more than $8.3 million to resolve allegations it violated the False Claims Act by offering improper payments to referring cardiologists, the U.S. Department of Justice announced Friday.
Federal prosecutors allege that between September 2016 and January 2025, Modern Nuclear Inc. (MNI) submitted claims to federal healthcare programs that were linked to financial arrangements prohibited under the Anti-Kickback Statute. These arrangements allegedly included payments to cardiologists that exceeded fair market value in exchange for patient referrals and oversight of PET scans.
According to court documents, some of these payments covered time periods when physicians were not physically present at scan locations or were treating other patients. Prosecutors further alleged that certain services billed by MNI were rarely or never actually provided to patients.
The case highlights ongoing federal efforts to combat healthcare fraud, particularly arrangements where medical providers allegedly pay physicians for referrals rather than basing care decisions on patient needs.
MNI had attempted to justify its payment structure by citing a legal opinion that purportedly confirmed the payments reflected fair market value. However, investigators determined the opinion was based on inaccurate information and was later withdrawn by the consultant who issued it, significantly undermining the company’s defense.
“Paying illegal kickbacks to doctors so they refer patients undermines the integrity of federal healthcare programs and needlessly increases costs,” said First Assistant United States Attorney Bill Essayli. “Patients deserve care based on their medical need and not on a doctor or company’s financial interest.”
As part of the settlement, MNI has entered into a five-year corporate integrity agreement with the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services Office of Inspector General. This agreement requires the company to adopt strict compliance measures governing its relationships with referring physicians and to establish a comprehensive program addressing risks under the Anti-Kickback Statute.
An independent compliance expert will evaluate the effectiveness of the program over the five-year period, providing additional oversight to ensure the company’s business practices remain within legal boundaries.
The firm will pay $8,334,350, along with additional amounts tied to future revenue, according to the Justice Department. This structure ensures the government continues to recover funds as the company operates under the new compliance framework.
The settlement resolves a whistleblower lawsuit originally filed under the False Claims Act by Matt Lieberman and James Whitney. Under the qui tam provisions of the False Claims Act, private citizens can file lawsuits on behalf of the government when they believe entities are defrauding federal programs. As the whistleblowers who initiated the case, Lieberman and Whitney will receive 16% of the recovery amount, approximately $1.33 million.
The case involved extensive coordination between multiple federal agencies. The Justice Department’s Civil Division worked alongside the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Central District of California, with additional assistance from the Department of Health and Human Services Office of Inspector General and the Defense Criminal Investigative Service. Assistant U.S. Attorney Paul B. La Scala of the Civil Division’s Civil Fraud Section and Senior Trial Counsel Sanjay M. Bhambhani of the Justice Department’s Civil Division handled the legal proceedings.
The medical imaging industry, particularly advanced diagnostic services like PET scans, has been under increasing scrutiny in recent years as federal authorities work to control healthcare costs and eliminate improper financial relationships that could influence medical decision-making. PET scans, which use radioactive tracers to create detailed images of tissues and organs, are expensive procedures typically covered by Medicare and other federal healthcare programs when medically necessary.
This settlement represents one of several recent enforcement actions targeting allegedly improper relationships between diagnostic imaging facilities and referring physicians across the country.
Fact Checker
Verify the accuracy of this article using The Disinformation Commission analysis and real-time sources.
17 Comments
While the $8.3 million settlement is a significant penalty, one wonders if it truly fits the scope of the alleged violations. Stronger deterrents may be needed to prevent future kickback schemes in the medical sector.
That’s a fair critique. The financial penalty alone may not be enough to change behavior, especially for larger healthcare organizations. Supplementary measures like improved compliance programs could be warranted.
This settlement sends a clear message that the government will not tolerate kickback schemes that exploit federal healthcare programs. Maintaining integrity in the medical industry is paramount.
While the details of this case are concerning, it’s good to see the authorities taking action. Ensuring ethical practices and responsible use of public healthcare resources should be an ongoing imperative.
The alleged misconduct by this La Habra provider is disappointing, but I’m glad the Justice Department took action. Upholding ethical standards in healthcare benefits all stakeholders, from patients to taxpayers.
Concerning to hear about these kickback allegations against the La Habra medical provider. Proper oversight and accountability are critical in the healthcare industry to prevent fraud and abuse of taxpayer funds.
Indeed, the $8.3 million settlement suggests a serious breach of trust. Hopefully this case serves as a deterrent and leads to tighter controls around physician referrals and billing practices.
Curious to see if this case leads to further investigations of similar practices in the healthcare sector. Rooting out fraud and abuse requires ongoing vigilance and collaboration between regulators and providers.
A fair point. This settlement may just be the tip of the iceberg. Comprehensive audits and tighter controls will be needed to ensure compliance across the industry.
The Justice Department’s action against this La Habra company highlights an ongoing challenge in the healthcare sector. Vigilance is needed to root out fraudulent billing and unethical referral arrangements.
You’re absolutely right. These types of schemes undermine public trust and divert critical resources away from patient care. Rigorous oversight and tough penalties are essential deterrents.
This is a timely reminder that the healthcare sector must uphold the highest ethical standards. Paying doctors for patient referrals undermines the integrity of the system and wastes public resources.
You’re right. Transparency and strong anti-kickback policies are essential to protect patients and taxpayers. It will be interesting to see if this leads to further investigations in the industry.
Alleged improper payments to cardiologists by this medical provider are very concerning. Strict enforcement of anti-kickback laws is crucial to prevent abuse and ensure fair competition in healthcare.
This case highlights the importance of robust whistleblower protections and reporting mechanisms to uncover fraudulent practices in the healthcare industry. Empowering insiders to come forward is crucial.
Kudos to the Justice Department for pursuing this case and securing a substantial settlement. Cracking down on kickbacks in the medical sector should remain a top priority to safeguard public funds and patient trust.
I agree. Vigilant enforcement sends a strong message and helps deter future misconduct. Maintaining a culture of accountability in healthcare benefits everyone, from providers to patients.