Listen to the article
A brief verbal slip by Rep. Ilhan Omar has been amplified across social media platforms, with critics using the out-of-context clip to question her knowledge of basic history and even call for her deportation.
In the 13-second clip that has garnered millions of views, Omar appears to refer to “World War Eleven” during a press conference about the Neighbors Not Enemies Act, proposed legislation aimed at repealing the Alien Enemies Act of 1798. The brief snippet shows Omar stating, “The last time the Alien Enemies Act was invoked, it was used to detain and deport German, Japanese, Italian immigrants during World War Eleven.”
The clip was widely circulated by conservative social media accounts, including Libs of TikTok, operated by activist Chaya Raichik, which alone garnered over 700,000 views on X (formerly Twitter). Many posts accompanying the clip mocked Omar, suggesting she misunderstood Roman numerals or lacked basic historical knowledge.
However, the full, unedited footage from the January 22, 2025, press conference in Washington, D.C., reveals that Omar immediately corrected herself after the verbal slip, clearly stating, “Oh—two, sorry.” The complete context makes it evident that she was referring to World War II and understood the historical period she was discussing.
The Alien Enemies Act, which Omar referenced, was indeed used during World War II as part of the legal justification for the U.S. government’s detention and deportation of immigrants from countries with which the United States was at war. This notably included the internment of Japanese Americans, one of the most controversial domestic policies enacted during the conflict.
The misleading framing of Omar’s momentary verbal slip comes amid heightened scrutiny of the Minnesota Representative for unrelated matters. Recently, Vice President JD Vance publicly alleged that Omar had committed immigration fraud—claims her office has strongly denied. These accusations have fueled renewed calls among some critics for her deportation, despite the fact that, as a naturalized U.S. citizen, Omar could only face deportation following a formal and successful denaturalization process through the courts.
Political analysts note that Omar, one of the first Muslim women elected to Congress and a member of the progressive “Squad,” has long been a target of intense criticism from conservative media outlets and political figures. Her advocacy for progressive policies, critique of U.S. foreign policy, and personal background as a Somali refugee have made her particularly vulnerable to such attacks.
Media literacy experts point out that this incident exemplifies a common tactic in the current digital media environment: isolating brief moments from longer speeches or events, removing contextual information, and presenting them as evidence of incompetence or malfeasance. The rapid spread of such content is facilitated by social media algorithms that tend to amplify emotionally charged and divisive content.
The incident underscores the challenges of maintaining factual accuracy in a fragmented media landscape where clips can be easily edited and shared without proper context. While Omar did momentarily misspeak, the full record demonstrates that she understood the historical reference and corrected herself immediately—context that was deliberately omitted from the viral clips circulating online.
As political tensions continue to rise ahead of upcoming elections, media observers caution that such selective editing of political figures’ statements is likely to increase, highlighting the importance of seeking original sources and complete context when evaluating viral political content.
Fact Checker
Verify the accuracy of this article using The Disinformation Commission analysis and real-time sources.
11 Comments
This seems like a relatively minor verbal gaffe that’s been blown out of proportion. I appreciate the fact check to provide proper context around Rep. Omar’s comments.
Agreed, the outrage over this seems exaggerated. Responsible reporting should focus on the substance of her remarks, not seize on brief slips of the tongue.
Thanks for the thorough fact check. It’s clear Rep. Omar misspoke initially, but promptly corrected herself. Responsible reporting should focus on the content of her remarks, not jump on brief verbal slips.
This fact check provides helpful context around Rep. Omar’s comments. While a verbal mistake, her immediate self-correction shows she clearly understands the historical details. Responsible reporting should avoid sensationalizing minor gaffes.
Agreed, the key is whether the person recognizes and corrects their mistake, which Rep. Omar did here. Focusing too much on brief slips of the tongue distracts from the substance of the discussion.
I appreciate the effort to provide full context around Rep. Omar’s comments. Fact-checking is important to avoid perpetuating misinformation, even when it involves public figures. Her self-correction shows she has a solid grasp of history.
Interesting to see the full context around Rep. Omar’s comment. While a verbal slip, it’s good she corrected herself right away. Fact-checking is important to provide the full story, rather than taking clips out of context.
Absolutely, the full video shows she quickly recognized and clarified her mistake. Responsible reporting is key to avoid spreading misinformation, even unintentionally.
It’s good to see the full video footage examined here. Verbal mistakes happen, but the key is whether the person corrects themselves, which Rep. Omar clearly did. Fact-checking is important to avoid spreading misinformation.
This fact check highlights the importance of reporting responsibly and avoiding the temptation to sensationalize minor verbal mistakes. Rep. Omar’s immediate self-correction demonstrates her understanding of the historical details.
Exactly, responsible reporting should focus on the substance of remarks, not jump on brief slips of the tongue. Her self-correction shows she has a good grasp of the facts.