Listen to the article
Immigration Wave Drives U.S. Rental Housing Demand to New Heights, Federal Report Finds
The average American renter now pays approximately $2,000 monthly, reflecting a dramatic 36% increase over just five years, according to Zillow data. A newly released report from the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) points to a significant factor behind this surge: unprecedented immigration levels during the Biden administration have substantially amplified housing demand, particularly in the rental sector.
HUD’s Worst Case Housing Needs 2025 Report to Congress, drawing on the 2023 American Housing Survey, documents a remarkable demographic shift. Between 2021 and 2024, the U.S. foreign-born population expanded by approximately six million people—what the agency characterizes as the largest population increase over such a compressed timeframe in American history.
This population growth has translated directly into heightened housing pressure nationwide. The federal agency estimates that immigration accounted for roughly two-thirds of total rental demand growth across the country during this period, with some regions seeing immigration responsible for up to 100 percent of housing demand increases.
The report examines the broader immigration picture rather than focusing exclusively on undocumented migrants. However, it comes as the Pew Research Center estimates the undocumented population reached approximately 14 million people in 2023.
California and New York have experienced particularly pronounced effects from this immigration-driven demand, according to HUD’s analysis. The national growth rate of households headed by non-citizens nearly doubled after 2019—from about 7 percent between 2015-2019 to 13 percent from 2019-2023. This acceleration occurred during a period when housing supply was already severely constrained.
Housing analysts who spoke with NPR caution against viewing immigration as the sole cause of America’s housing challenges. Many argue that today’s housing shortage represents the culmination of problems years or even decades in the making.
Bankrate analysis traces the origins of the current housing crisis to the 2007-2008 Great Recession, when homebuilding activity collapsed dramatically. Construction companies went bankrupt, financing disappeared, and new housing starts plummeted. Critically, the industry never fully rebounded to pre-recession building levels, according to Federal Reserve data from St. Louis.
Housing market experts typically consider a balanced market to require five to six months of available housing supply. Currently, the U.S. has approximately 3.5 months of inventory—an improvement from pandemic-era lows but still significantly below healthy levels, Bankrate reports.
Within this context, critics contend that immigration has intensified pressure on an already dysfunctional housing market rather than creating the crisis outright. NPR’s reporting supports this view, noting that undocumented migrants primarily increase rental demand, but within a system already hampered by chronic underbuilding, restrictive zoning policies, workforce shortages, and escalating construction costs.
Large-scale investors have further complicated the housing landscape. According to Realtor.com, investor buyers accounted for 14.8% of all home purchases in 2024’s first quarter—the highest proportion since the company began tracking this metric. Many of these properties were acquired for rental or resale purposes, effectively reducing the housing stock available to individual buyers and exerting additional upward pressure on rental rates.
The result is a market where prospective homeowners find themselves increasingly locked out, rental supply continues to tighten, and housing costs maintain their upward trajectory.
HUD’s report intensifies an already contentious debate. One perspective highlights how immigration, including unauthorized entry, has substantially increased housing demand, particularly in the rental sector. The opposing viewpoint, championed by economists and housing advocates, maintains that these demand pressures would be far less disruptive if the United States had sustained consistent homebuilding activity over the past decade and a half.
As policymakers grapple with these interconnected challenges, American renters and potential homebuyers continue to face a market characterized by limited options and historically high costs.
Fact Checker
Verify the accuracy of this article using The Disinformation Commission analysis and real-time sources.
10 Comments
This report provides valuable information, but I’d encourage further research to validate the findings and explore potential alternative explanations.
This is an important issue that deserves rigorous, impartial study. I hope policymakers can use these insights to develop effective solutions for affordable housing.
Interesting report on the impact of immigration on US rental costs. I’d be curious to see more data on how this varies across different regions and demographics.
Yes, it would be helpful to understand the regional nuances and implications for low-income renters in particular.
The scale of immigration’s impact on rental demand is remarkable. I wonder how this trend compares to other major drivers of the housing crisis, like limited supply and speculative investment.
That’s a great point. Disentangling the various factors at play will be crucial for crafting effective policies.
The findings on the outsized role of immigration in driving rental demand seem plausible, but I’d want to see a more comprehensive analysis before drawing firm conclusions.
Agreed, it’s a complex issue that requires a balanced look at all the factors at play.
The rental cost crisis is a major challenge, and immigration is clearly a significant factor. But we need to look at the full picture to address this problem effectively.
Well said. A nuanced, data-driven approach is essential here.