Listen to the article
Minneapolis Police Chief Criticizes Federal Immigration Officers After Controversial Arrest Attempt
Minneapolis Police Chief Brian O’Hara has publicly criticized federal immigration agents following a confrontation where an Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) officer was seen kneeling on a woman’s back as she lay on a snow bank before attempting to drag her to a vehicle.
The incident, which occurred Monday near a Somali business district in Minneapolis, was captured on video by onlookers who can be heard shouting at agents to release the woman, claiming she was pregnant and couldn’t breathe.
“We have been training our officers for the last five years very, very intensely on de-escalation,” O’Hara said during a Tuesday news conference. “But unfortunately that is not, that is often not what we are seeing from other agencies in the city.”
According to O’Hara, city police were called to the scene by a federal agent requesting assistance. Upon arrival, Minneapolis officers did not observe violence against federal officers and chose to leave in an effort to de-escalate the situation. The police chief suggested that “other law enforcement agencies” were using “questionable methods.”
The confrontation comes amid rising tensions in the Minneapolis-St. Paul area, where federal authorities have intensified immigration enforcement operations targeting the region’s Somali community, the largest in the United States. Community advocates say the crackdown has created fear and disruption in an already vulnerable population.
Lauryn Spencer, a witness who began recording after hearing warning whistles and honking, described aggressive behavior by federal agents from the outset. “They were being very aggressive from the beginning, like there was never a time where they attempted to use diplomacy,” Spencer said. She claimed she was shoved back by an officer when she tried to ask the woman’s name and that agents sprayed chemical irritants at the crowd.
Department of Homeland Security assistant secretary Tricia McLaughlin offered a different account, stating that federal officers were targeting a vehicle when protesters “threw rocks, chunks of ice, assaulted officers and used pepper spray” against them. According to McLaughlin, officers attempted to arrest the woman because she “rushed an ICE vehicle and attempted to vandalize it,” but abandoned the arrest after being surrounded by protesters.
McLaughlin added that officers sustained multiple injuries including cuts, and two people were charged with assaulting federal officers and remain in custody.
Former Minnesota state legislator Hodan Hassan expressed concern about escalating enforcement tactics. “The first week, they were not very aggressive. They were stopping people. Second week, we saw them really aggressive,” she said.
The incident occurred just two miles from where George Floyd was killed in 2020 by a Minneapolis police officer who knelt on his neck – an event that sparked nationwide protests demanding racial justice and police reform. The parallels between the two incidents, both involving law enforcement officers kneeling on individuals, have not been lost on community members.
The confrontation highlights ongoing tensions between local and federal law enforcement approaches to policing and community relations. While Minneapolis police have emphasized de-escalation tactics following the Floyd killing and subsequent reforms, critics suggest that federal immigration enforcement has not embraced similar changes.
Immigration advocates have raised concerns about the broader impact of aggressive enforcement actions on immigrant communities, pointing to decreased cooperation with law enforcement, heightened fear, and potential civil rights violations. Meanwhile, federal officials maintain that their operations target individuals who pose public safety threats.
As the immigration enforcement operation continues in the Twin Cities area, community leaders and civil liberties organizations are monitoring the situation and calling for greater accountability and transparency from federal agencies operating in their neighborhoods.
Fact Checker
Verify the accuracy of this article using The Disinformation Commission analysis and real-time sources.
13 Comments
While immigration enforcement is a complex and sensitive issue, the actions taken by federal agents in this incident seem questionable at best. The Minneapolis police chief’s criticism is warranted and highlights the need for more oversight and accountability.
I share your concerns. Federal agents must operate with professionalism and respect the authority of local law enforcement, who are better positioned to defuse volatile situations and maintain community trust.
This incident raises serious concerns about the tactics used by federal immigration agents in communities. The police chief’s criticism of their ‘questionable methods’ is warranted – de-escalation should be the priority when dealing with vulnerable people.
I agree, the video footage is quite disturbing. Federal agents need to be held accountable for their actions and ensure they are following proper protocols to protect the safety and rights of all individuals.
This incident reinforces the importance of clear communication and alignment of tactics between federal and local law enforcement. The police chief’s criticism highlights the need for reforms to ensure vulnerable community members are treated with dignity and respect.
The police chief’s comments suggest a concerning pattern of aggressive tactics by federal immigration agents that are at odds with local de-escalation protocols. Improved coordination and training across agencies is clearly needed to avoid further confrontations.
The confrontational approach taken by the federal agents in this incident is concerning and runs counter to the Minneapolis police department’s emphasis on de-escalation. Improved training and oversight is needed to ensure federal immigration enforcement aligns with local community priorities.
While immigration enforcement is a complex issue, the federal agents’ tactics in this incident appear heavy-handed and inappropriate. The police chief’s criticism is warranted, and hopefully it prompts reforms to ensure better coordination and de-escalation protocols across agencies.
The Minneapolis police chief’s public rebuke of the federal agents’ actions is a necessary step to hold them accountable and rebuild trust within the community. Overly aggressive immigration enforcement tactics have no place when public safety should be the top priority.
This clash highlights the need for better coordination and alignment of tactics between federal immigration agents and local police departments. The community’s safety and civil liberties must be the top priority.
Agreed. The police chief’s comments suggest a disconnect that should be addressed through policy reforms and joint training efforts. Overly aggressive tactics by federal agents can seriously undermine community relations.
It’s good to see the Minneapolis police chief standing up for his officers’ commitment to de-escalation. Federal agencies should work in coordination with local law enforcement to ensure the community’s trust is not eroded.
Absolutely. Maintaining public trust is critical, especially for sensitive immigration enforcement actions. Improved communication and training across agencies could help prevent such confrontational incidents in the future.