Listen to the article
Former Manchester City Star Nasri Fights French Tax Authorities Over Alleged Dubai Residency
Former Manchester City midfielder Samir Nasri is locked in a contentious legal battle with French tax authorities, who claim the 38-year-old footballer owes more than 5.5 million euros ($6.3 million) in wealth and income taxes spanning the period from 2018 to 2025.
At the heart of the dispute is whether Nasri has been genuinely residing in Dubai as he claims, or if he has maintained his primary residence in France, which would subject him to the country’s tax regime. In March, a Paris court approved the temporary seizure of some of Nasri’s assets, including bank accounts and a provisional mortgage on one of his Paris properties, pending resolution of the case.
Jean-Noël Sanchez, Nasri’s attorney, vehemently disputes the allegations, calling the 5.5 million euro figure “imaginary” and arguing that his client is being unfairly targeted. “The problem is that France has decided for Mr. Nasri — and others, for that matter — to attack all those who live in the United Arab Emirates,” Sanchez said in a phone interview on Tuesday.
French tax authorities have employed unusual evidence to support their claim that Nasri’s primary residence remains in France. Court documents reveal they tracked 212 Deliveroo food delivery orders to one of Nasri’s Paris addresses in 2022 alone. They also analyzed his travel patterns, alleging the former France international spent 487 days in France between 2021 and 2023, compared to just 226 days in the UAE.
Sanchez challenges this evidence, questioning whether Nasri himself placed the food delivery orders. “Did his mother place orders, his sister, his brother, his friends?” the lawyer asked. “The administration might today believe that it’s on solid ground in saying that he lives in France, but it will have to prove that. And that is not going to be proven by the 212 Deliveroos.”
The case highlights the increasing scrutiny high-net-worth individuals face from tax authorities worldwide, particularly athletes and celebrities who claim residence in tax-advantaged jurisdictions. The UAE, with its zero personal income tax rate, has become a popular destination for wealthy Europeans seeking to reduce their tax burdens.
According to Sanchez, Nasri genuinely lives in Dubai with his partner and their son, who attends school there. “He doesn’t live in France,” Sanchez insisted, adding that Nasri “is a perfect French citizen” who properly files tax returns and pays taxes on income earned in France.
The dispute could drag on for years before reaching a final resolution. Sanchez has already appealed the asset seizure ruling while maintaining that his client’s presumption of innocence is being violated.
This case against Nasri comes amid France’s broader crackdown on tax avoidance and residency schemes. French authorities have increasingly challenged claims of foreign residency by examining digital footprints, spending patterns, and physical presence indicators.
Nasri, who retired from professional football in 2020, enjoyed a successful career spanning several top European clubs. Beyond his stint at Manchester City, where he won two Premier League titles, Nasri also played for Arsenal and Marseille. He represented the French national team 41 times before his international career ended in 2013.
Tax disputes involving high-profile footballers have become increasingly common across Europe. In recent years, stars including Cristiano Ronaldo, Lionel Messi, and Neymar have faced similar scrutiny from tax authorities in Spain and other countries. These cases often revolve around complex questions of residency, image rights payments, and offshore structures.
The outcome of Nasri’s case could set an important precedent for how tax residency is determined in an era when digital evidence and consumption patterns can be tracked with unprecedented detail.
Fact Checker
Verify the accuracy of this article using The Disinformation Commission analysis and real-time sources.
9 Comments
The French authorities’ use of Deliveroo orders to challenge Nasri’s Dubai residency is an intriguing tactic. I wonder what other evidence they may have gathered to support their position.
It’s understandable that Nasri’s lawyer would view the 5.5 million euro figure as ‘imaginary.’ Residency requirements can be complex, so I hope the courts carefully weigh all the facts.
This tax dispute over Nasri’s residency seems quite complex. It will be interesting to see how the courts weigh the evidence around his Dubai living versus potential ties to France. Nasri’s lawyer makes a fair point about the authorities targeting those living in the UAE.
Agreed, the use of Deliveroo orders as evidence is quite unusual. Residency disputes can get very messy, especially for high-profile figures.
This case highlights the challenges high-net-worth individuals can face when navigating international tax regimes. I’m curious to see how Nasri’s legal team defends his claimed Dubai residency against the French authorities’ allegations.
The temporary asset seizures ordered by the Paris court suggest the French tax authorities believe they have a strong case. But Nasri’s lawyer seems determined to fight this aggressively.
The alleged 5.5 million euro tax bill is a staggering amount. I’m curious to learn more about the specific tax laws and requirements in France versus the UAE that are at the heart of this dispute.
It will be important for Nasri to thoroughly document his residency and disprove the authorities’ claims. Tax disputes of this scale can be very drawn-out and contentious.
Tax disputes involving professional athletes can get very messy, as their lives often span multiple countries. I’ll be following this case with interest to see how the courts ultimately rule on Nasri’s residency status.