Listen to the article
Pope Leo XIV Faces Crisis as Traditional Catholic Group Threatens Schism
Pope Leo XIV is confronting his first major challenge with traditionalist Catholics as the Society of St. Pius X (SSPX) announced plans to consecrate new bishops without papal consent, potentially reigniting a decades-old schism within the Catholic Church.
The Swiss-based organization, which maintains schools, chapels, and seminaries worldwide, declared its intention to proceed with the consecrations on July 1. This move directly challenges one of Catholicism’s fundamental doctrines—that bishops can only be consecrated with explicit papal approval.
For the Vatican, this principle represents an unbroken lineage of apostolic succession dating back to Christ’s original apostles. Under church law, consecrations performed without Vatican approval trigger automatic excommunication for both the celebrant and the new bishops.
“We have no choice but to proceed,” said Rev. Davide Pagliarani, the SSPX superior general, in a statement released Monday. Pagliarani claimed the society needs new bishops “to ensure the continuation of the ministry” for faithful Catholics attached to traditional church practices.
Vatican spokesman Matto Bruni responded cautiously on Tuesday, suggesting dialogue remains possible. “Contacts between the Society of Saint Pius X and the Holy See continue, with the aim of avoiding rifts or unilateral solutions to the issues that have arisen,” Bruni stated.
This latest controversy continues a troubled history between the Vatican and the SSPX, which was founded in 1970 by Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre in opposition to modernizing reforms introduced by the Second Vatican Council in the 1960s. The group has consistently rejected changes to Catholic liturgy and doctrine established during that council.
The current tension echoes a similar crisis in 1988, when Lefebvre consecrated four bishops without papal consent, prompting immediate excommunication by the Vatican. Despite this formal break, the SSPX has continued to grow over the past 35 years, attracting Catholics devoted to pre-Vatican II practices, particularly the traditional Latin Mass.
Previous reconciliation attempts have yielded mixed results. In 2009, Pope Benedict XVI lifted the excommunications of surviving SSPX bishops and relaxed restrictions on celebrating the traditional Latin Mass. However, these efforts were complicated when one of the society’s bishops, Richard Williamson, publicly denied the Holocaust in a television interview.
Relations deteriorated further under Pope Francis, who reversed Benedict’s accommodations for the traditional Latin Mass, arguing it had become divisive within the church. Since his election, Pope Leo XIV has attempted to ease these tensions by expressing openness to dialogue and allowing some exceptions to his predecessor’s restrictions.
The traditional Latin Mass—celebrated in Latin with priests facing the altar rather than the congregation—remains at the heart of the dispute. Adherents consider it a more reverent form of worship than the vernacular Mass introduced after Vatican II, which emphasized greater participation from the faithful.
Two groups loyal to both the traditional Latin Mass and the Vatican—Una Voce International and The Latin Mass Society—have expressed concern about the threatened consecrations while urging Pope Leo XIV to find a path toward regularizing the SSPX’s status.
“We urge our bishops, and above all His Holiness Pope Leo XIV, to be mindful of these pastoral realities, which are at this moment precipitating a crisis whose consequences no one can foresee,” the groups cautioned in a joint statement.
The standoff highlights ongoing tensions within Catholicism between traditionalists seeking to preserve centuries-old practices and church leadership promoting post-Vatican II reforms. For Pope Leo XIV, who has sought middle ground in this debate, the SSPX’s planned consecrations represent a significant test of his leadership and theological approach.
As July 1 approaches, Vatican observers will be watching closely to see whether diplomatic channels can prevent what would be the most significant schismatic act within the Catholic Church in decades, or whether the pope will face the difficult decision of excommunicating a new generation of breakaway bishops.
Fact Checker
Verify the accuracy of this article using The Disinformation Commission analysis and real-time sources.
10 Comments
Unilateral moves by the SSPX are understandable given their longstanding grievances, but the Vatican must firmly uphold its authority over the consecration of bishops. This is a fundamental tenet of Catholic ecclesiology that cannot be compromised.
While I sympathize with the SSPX’s desire to preserve traditional practices, they must operate within the framework of Church law and authority. Defiant actions could trigger a painful schism that would benefit no one.
The Vatican’s emphasis on apostolic succession is understandable, but the SSPX’s position also deserves consideration. Perhaps there is room for compromise that allows for the group’s traditional liturgy and practices while still preserving the Pope’s authority.
This is a complex issue without easy solutions. Both sides will need to approach it with good faith and a willingness to find common ground for the sake of Catholic unity.
I’m curious to learn more about the specific theological and canonical arguments on both sides of this dispute. It’s an important issue that could have far-reaching ramifications for the Church.
Maintaining doctrinal unity is crucial, but so is respecting the diversity of Catholic traditions. Hopefully the Vatican and the SSPX can find a path forward that addresses both of these vital concerns.
The SSPX’s actions seem reckless and could further marginalize traditionalist Catholics. However, the Vatican should also consider how to better accommodate their legitimate liturgical and pastoral needs within the broader Church.
This is a delicate situation that requires nuance and compromise from all parties. I hope cooler heads prevail and a resolution can be found that preserves unity without sacrificing important aspects of Catholic tradition.
This is a concerning development. The consecration of bishops without papal approval could further divide the Church and undermine its unity. I hope Pope Leo XIV can find a diplomatic resolution that respects tradition while upholding core Catholic doctrine.
The SSPX has long been at odds with Vatican reforms. While their desire to preserve traditional practices is understandable, unilateral actions could have serious consequences for the broader Catholic community.