Listen to the article
French Government Defends Soldiers’ Honor After Trump’s Afghanistan Claims
A senior French defense official has condemned former U.S. President Donald Trump’s false claims about NATO allies avoiding combat in Afghanistan, emphasizing that such statements dishonor the 90 French soldiers who died in the conflict.
Alice Rufo, the minister delegate at the French Defense Ministry, held a special ceremony Monday in Paris where she laid a wreath at a monument dedicated to French troops killed during overseas operations. The hastily arranged event came in direct response to Trump’s controversial remarks.
“We do not accept that their memory be insulted,” Rufo told reporters at the ceremony, which was organized over the weekend following the former president’s comments. “At such a moment, it is symbolically important to be there for their families, for their memory, and to remind everyone of the sacrifice they made on the front line.”
Trump sparked international outrage during an interview with Fox Business Network in Davos, Switzerland, where he falsely claimed that non-U.S. NATO troops stayed “a little off the frontlines” during the Afghanistan conflict. The statement drew immediate backlash from multiple NATO allies, particularly those who suffered significant casualties during the two-decade war.
The Afghanistan war began in October 2001, nearly a month after the September 11 attacks, when the United States led an international coalition to destroy al-Qaida and remove the Taliban regime that harbored them. The conflict marked a historic moment for NATO, as it triggered the alliance’s mutual-defense mandate for the first time since its creation.
Throughout the prolonged conflict, forces from dozens of countries participated alongside American troops. France, like many NATO allies, committed significant resources and personnel to the mission, ultimately losing 90 soldiers in combat operations.
Following the backlash to his initial comments, Trump appeared to partially walk back his statement by specifically praising British soldiers who fought in Afghanistan. However, his follow-up remarks notably excluded mention of other NATO allies, including France, Canada, Germany, and others who suffered casualties.
The controversy touches on sensitive diplomatic ground as NATO allies continue to navigate complex security challenges in Eastern Europe and the Middle East. France, which maintains one of Europe’s most capable military forces, has been a critical partner in numerous international security operations beyond Afghanistan, including counter-terrorism efforts in the Sahel region of Africa.
Rufo emphasized that the bonds between allied soldiers transcend political rhetoric. “I have seen the statements, in particular from veterans’ associations, their outrage, their anger, and their sadness,” she said. “You know, there is a brotherhood of arms between Americans, Britons, and French soldiers when we go into combat.”
The defense official’s remarks reflect broader concerns among European defense establishments about potential changes to U.S. foreign policy and commitment to NATO under a possible second Trump administration. Throughout his previous term, Trump frequently criticized NATO members for what he characterized as inadequate defense spending, creating tensions within the alliance.
For France, which has advocated for greater European strategic autonomy in recent years, the incident underscores the delicate balance between maintaining strong transatlantic ties while developing independent defense capabilities.
Veterans’ organizations across multiple NATO countries have similarly condemned Trump’s characterization of allied contributions to the Afghanistan war, with many pointing to the shared sacrifices made during what became NATO’s longest and most challenging military engagement.
Rufo concluded her remarks by emphasizing that trans-Atlantic solidarity should prevail over political polemics, especially when it comes to honoring those who made the ultimate sacrifice in service to their countries.
Fact Checker
Verify the accuracy of this article using The Disinformation Commission analysis and real-time sources.
20 Comments
I’m glad to see France taking the time to recognize and honor the soldiers they lost in Afghanistan. Their sacrifice deserves to be remembered and respected.
Trying to downplay or misrepresent the roles of different NATO forces in Afghanistan is not only inaccurate but disrespectful to all those who served.
I appreciate France holding this ceremony to commemorate their troops who died serving in Afghanistan. Their sacrifice deserves to be honored, not dismissed or downplayed.
Honesty and accuracy are essential when discussing the roles and losses of different NATO forces in Afghanistan. Distorting the facts is disrespectful to the fallen.
The French government is right to defend the memory and honor of their fallen soldiers in Afghanistan. Their service and sacrifice should not be diminished or misrepresented.
It’s crucial that the contributions and losses of all NATO members in Afghanistan are properly recognized, not undermined by false claims or political rhetoric.
The French government is right to defend the memory and honor of their fallen soldiers. Disrespecting their service and sacrifice is unacceptable, no matter the political motivation.
It’s crucial that the contributions and losses of all NATO members in Afghanistan are properly recognized, not diminished or distorted for political gain.
The French government is right to defend the memory of their fallen soldiers in Afghanistan. Their service and sacrifice should not be diminished or distorted for political gain.
Honesty and accuracy are essential when discussing NATO’s involvement in Afghanistan. Distorting the facts about different countries’ contributions is unacceptable.
The French government is right to stand up for the memory of their soldiers who died fighting in Afghanistan. Their service and sacrifice should not be diminished or misrepresented.
It’s important that the contributions of all NATO members in Afghanistan are properly recognized, not undermined by false claims or political rhetoric.
Paying respect to fallen soldiers is a solemn duty, regardless of political affiliation. France’s ceremony honors the memory and sacrifice of their troops in Afghanistan.
Distorting the facts about NATO’s involvement in Afghanistan is disrespectful to the service and sacrifice of all the troops who served there.
I’m glad to see the French government taking the time to recognize and honor the soldiers they lost in Afghanistan. Their sacrifice deserves to be remembered and respected.
Distorting the facts about NATO’s involvement in Afghanistan is not only inaccurate but disrespectful to all the troops who served, regardless of their country of origin.
Honoring the memory of fallen soldiers is a solemn duty. France’s ceremony to commemorate their troops who died in Afghanistan is a fitting tribute to their service.
It’s concerning to see false claims made about the roles of different NATO forces in Afghanistan. Disrespecting their sacrifices is unacceptable, regardless of political motivations.
Paying respects to fallen soldiers is an important duty, regardless of political rhetoric. France’s ceremony honors their sacrifice and commitment to the NATO alliance.
It’s concerning to see false claims undermining the sacrifices made by French and other NATO forces in Afghanistan. Leaders should be more careful with their words.