Listen to the article
‘Modern’ Nativity Scene Sparks Cultural Debate Across Europe
Controversy is mounting across Europe as local governments and public institutions reimagine traditional Christmas symbols, sparking intense debates about cultural heritage, inclusion and religious expression.
In Brussels, the unveiling of a contemporary nativity scene in the city’s iconic Grand Place has generated significant backlash. The installation, created by German artist Victoria-Maria, features faceless figures in place of the traditional Holy Family representation. Promoted as an inclusive artistic display, the modernist interpretation has instead drawn sharp criticism and even vandalism.
Belgian national soccer player Thomas Meunier captured public sentiment when he wrote on social media, “We’ve hit rock bottom… and we keep digging,” a post that quickly gained thousands of shares. The controversy has forced Brussels Mayor Philippe Close to defend the decision at a press conference.
“In this Christmas period, we need to tone it down,” Close explained, noting that while Brussels chose to maintain a nativity display, other cities had removed theirs entirely. “The old Nativity scene had been in use for 25 years and was showing many defects. It was time to take a new direction.”
Close emphasized that the city supports the artist and does not want to see her personally attacked despite the controversy. The municipality had initially framed the installation as part of a broader effort to create more inclusive holiday displays.
The Brussels dispute is just one example of a wider trend across Europe where traditional Christmas symbols are being reconsidered in public spaces. In the United Kingdom, a publicly funded museum has drawn criticism for suggesting that Father Christmas should be “decolonized.”
Simone LaCorbinière, Joint Head of Culture Change at Brighton and Hove Museums, wrote in a controversial blog post that the traditional image of Santa Claus was “too white and too male.” She criticized the concept of judging children through a “naughty or nice” list and urged parents to imagine Santa as a more diverse figure who “celebrates cultural exchange” rather than judges different cultures.
“Have Santa learn about different cultures rather than judge them,” LaCorbinière suggested, proposing stories that show him experiencing different traditions. She also advocated for including “Mother Christmases,” arguing that “patriarchy and colonialism went hand in hand.”
The proposal has drawn strong rebuke from politicians, with Conservative MP Sir Alec Shelbrooke calling it “the worst possible use of taxpayer funds” and criticizing “woke do-gooders” for dampening festive cheer.
British schools have also entered the fray, with several institutions reportedly replacing traditional “Christmas sweater days” with more generic “winter” or “seasonal” attire events to avoid religious references, according to GB News. This shift toward more secular terminology has angered some parents and community members who see it as erasing cultural traditions.
Even Christmas music has become contentious. The UK’s recently passed Employment Rights Bill includes provisions regarding workplace harassment related to protected characteristics such as religion. Critics argue this legislation could potentially affect holiday music in workplaces, including traditional Christmas songs that have faced renewed scrutiny in recent years.
Lord Young, head of the UK’s Free Speech Union, expressed concern about the implications: “The Government didn’t listen, insisting we were being alarmist, but a ban on Christmas music and carol singing will be the least of it.”
These controversies highlight the tension between traditional cultural expressions and efforts to create more inclusive environments. As public institutions attempt to navigate increasingly diverse communities, the question of how to balance cultural heritage with religious neutrality remains unresolved.
For many Europeans, these changes represent an unwelcome erosion of cherished traditions and religious expression. For others, they reflect necessary evolution toward more inclusive public spaces. As the holiday season continues, the debate shows no signs of abating, raising fundamental questions about cultural identity in modern Europe.
Fact Checker
Verify the accuracy of this article using The Disinformation Commission analysis and real-time sources.
16 Comments
This debate over Christmas traditions in Europe speaks to the broader challenges of preserving cultural identity in an increasingly globalized world. It’s a complex issue without easy solutions, as communities grapple with maintaining heritage while also embracing diversity.
Well said. Striking the right balance between honoring the past and being open to change is an ongoing challenge that communities will continue to wrestle with.
Interesting to see how cities are reimagining Christmas traditions across Europe. While artistic expression is valuable, it’s understandable that some feel these changes go too far and undermine cultural heritage. Balancing inclusivity and tradition is a delicate challenge.
I agree, it’s a complex issue without easy answers. Preserving cultural identity while being open to new perspectives is important.
I’m curious to see how this debate unfolds. There’s clearly a desire to evolve Christmas celebrations, but the pushback shows how change can be challenging when it comes to deeply rooted cultural norms.
Absolutely. These types of discussions around preserving heritage while also embracing diversity will likely continue as societies grapple with balancing tradition and progress.
The controversy over the ‘modern’ nativity scene in Brussels underscores the sensitivity around religious and cultural symbols, even in seemingly secular public spaces. This debate speaks to the broader challenges of preserving heritage while also embracing diversity in an increasingly globalized world.
Well said. Finding the right balance between honoring the past and being inclusive of different perspectives is an ongoing challenge that communities will continue to grapple with.
This debate over Christmas traditions in Europe highlights the complex interplay between preserving the past and embracing progress. It will be interesting to see how cities navigate this balance going forward, as they seek to be more inclusive while also honoring their cultural roots.
Absolutely. These types of discussions are sure to continue as communities work to find the right approach that respects tradition while also being open to new perspectives and expressions.
The controversy over the ‘modern’ nativity scene in Brussels highlights the sensitivity around religious and cultural symbolism, even in seemingly secular public spaces. It will be interesting to see if other cities pursue similar artistic reinterpretations of Christmas traditions.
You raise a good point. As cities aim to be more inclusive, they’ll have to navigate the fine line between honoring the past and evolving with the times. It’s a delicate balance.
The backlash over the contemporary nativity scene in Brussels is a testament to the deep-rooted significance of these long-standing traditions. While artistic expression is valuable, drastically altering such symbolic displays can understandably upset many people.
I agree. Preserving cultural heritage is important, but so is creating more inclusive spaces. Finding the right approach that respects both is the real challenge here.
The backlash over changes to Christmas displays in Europe highlights the deep emotions and sensitivities around these long-standing traditions. Modernizing symbols of faith and community can be seen as disrespectful by some.
You make a good point. Tradition often holds great meaning, and altering those practices can stir up strong reactions, even if the intent is to be more inclusive.