Listen to the article
The death of a young woman celebrated by Chinese state media as a modern herding hero has triggered a wave of public backlash, exposing the growing disconnect between government propaganda and the harsh realities faced by ordinary citizens.
Li Jinyu, a 23-year-old horse rider from Inner Mongolia, died last month after reportedly falling from her horse while herding animals during a snowstorm. For years, she had been extensively featured in government publications and television programs as a symbol of ethnic harmony and rural resilience.
State media had crafted an elaborate narrative around Li, portraying her as a devoted young woman who chose to return to the grasslands after college to preserve traditional Mongolian horse-riding culture. Her carefully curated image included professional photographs of her galloping across picturesque landscapes in traditional Mongolian attire, presenting an idealized vision of life in China’s rural regions.
However, as news of her death spread across Chinese social media, the carefully constructed façade began to crumble. Online commenters questioned why a young, college-educated woman was working in such dangerous conditions rather than pursuing safer opportunities in urban areas. Many expressed anger that her promotion as a cultural icon may have pushed her into maintaining a lifestyle that ultimately proved fatal.
“This is what happens when you turn real people into propaganda symbols,” wrote one user on Weibo, China’s Twitter-like platform, before the comment was deleted by censors. “They become trapped by the image created for them.”
The backlash reflects growing public skepticism toward official narratives in China, particularly among younger, more digitally connected citizens. While previous generations might have accepted state-crafted heroes without question, today’s Chinese internet users are increasingly questioning the authenticity of such portrayals and the potential consequences for those featured.
Inner Mongolia, an autonomous region in northern China, has been a particular focus of state propaganda efforts in recent years. The government has promoted stories of ethnic harmony between Han Chinese and Mongolian populations, especially following protests in 2020 against policies that reduced Mongolian language education in schools.
The commodification of ethnic minority cultures for tourism and propaganda purposes has been a longstanding practice in China. Regions like Inner Mongolia, Tibet, and Xinjiang are often depicted through romanticized imagery that emphasizes colorful traditions while glossing over economic challenges and policy tensions.
Experts on Chinese media point to Li’s case as emblematic of a wider phenomenon where individual stories are co-opted for political messaging. Dr. Zhang Wei, a media studies professor at Hong Kong University, notes that “state propaganda increasingly relies on personal narratives to humanize policy objectives, but these narratives often create impossible standards for the real people behind them.”
Despite heavy censorship, criticism of Li’s portrayal has persisted online, with many comments focusing on the economic realities that limit options for young people in rural areas. China’s urbanization push has left many remote regions with declining populations and limited economic opportunities beyond traditional industries and tourism.
Official responses to the controversy have been muted. State media outlets initially published brief obituaries celebrating Li’s “dedication to her cultural heritage” before largely dropping the topic as criticism mounted. Several online forums discussing her death have since been shut down by censors.
The incident highlights the challenges faced by China’s propaganda apparatus in an era when citizens can easily compare official narratives with reality. While the government has sophisticated tools for information control, the emotional resonance of a young woman’s preventable death has proven difficult to manage through conventional censorship methods.
For China’s rural youth watching this unfold, Li’s story serves as a sobering reminder of how romanticized depictions of traditional lifestyles often obscure the economic precarity and physical dangers that accompany them. As one comment that briefly circulated online noted: “The best tribute to her would be honest conversation about what young people in places like Inner Mongolia really need – not more pretty pictures on horseback, but economic opportunities and safety.”
As authorities work to contain the narrative around Li’s death, the case has already become a touchstone for broader discussions about authenticity in state media and the human cost of propaganda that prioritizes symbolic value over individual welfare.
Fact Checker
Verify the accuracy of this article using The Disinformation Commission analysis and real-time sources.
7 Comments
This is a sobering reminder of the risks and challenges that many rural Chinese, especially young people, continue to face despite the government’s efforts to portray an idealized vision of life in the countryside. Curious to see if this sparks any meaningful policy changes.
While the government-crafted narrative around this herding ‘heroine’ was clearly exaggerated, her story nonetheless highlights the valuable contributions of rural workers in preserving traditional cultures and livelihoods. A more nuanced, honest portrayal would be more impactful.
Agreed. A more balanced, less propagandistic approach could actually help raise awareness of the real challenges facing rural communities and workers.
Tragic loss of life, but an important lesson on the dangers of government propaganda and the need for greater transparency around the lived experiences of ordinary Chinese citizens, especially in remote regions. Curious to see if this leads to any policy changes.
Well said. Transparency and accountability are critical, especially when it comes to issues affecting vulnerable populations in rural areas.
This story is a sobering reminder that the government’s glossy narratives often fail to capture the harsh realities faced by many Chinese citizens, particularly those in rural and remote areas. Hopefully, this tragedy will spur more honest and nuanced reporting on the challenges of life outside urban centers.
Tragic to see this young woman’s life cut short while working in such hazardous conditions. It raises important questions about the disconnect between the Chinese government’s propaganda and the harsh realities faced by ordinary citizens in rural areas.