Listen to the article
President Donald Trump has launched a $10 billion lawsuit against the Internal Revenue Service, alleging the federal agency illegally leaked his confidential tax information to media outlets, including The New York Times and ProPublica.
According to a spokesman for Trump’s legal team, the lawsuit centers on claims that a “rogue, politically motivated” IRS employee disclosed private tax records belonging to Trump, his family members, and the Trump Organization. The legal action contends these disclosures constituted serious violations of federal privacy laws that protect taxpayer information.
The lawsuit comes amid ongoing scrutiny of Trump’s financial affairs that has persisted since his 2016 presidential campaign, when he broke with decades of precedent by refusing to voluntarily release his tax returns. This controversy has followed the former president through his administration and post-presidency years.
Tax privacy experts note that federal law strictly prohibits IRS employees from disclosing taxpayer information without authorization. Under Internal Revenue Code Section 6103, unauthorized disclosure of tax return information is a federal crime that can result in up to five years in prison and substantial fines.
“This lawsuit represents one of the largest privacy violation claims ever brought against a federal agency,” said Robert Shapiro, a tax attorney not involved in the case. “The $10 billion figure signals the Trump team believes the alleged leaks caused substantial damage to business interests and personal reputation.”
The New York Times published extensive investigative reports on Trump’s taxes in 2020, revealing that the former president paid minimal federal income taxes for many years. The Times stated at the time that its reporting was based on tax-return data extending over more than two decades. ProPublica has also published tax-related investigations focusing on America’s wealthiest individuals, including information about Trump.
Neither publication has been named as defendants in Trump’s lawsuit, which focuses specifically on the IRS as the alleged source of the leaked information.
The IRS has faced previous scrutiny over data security. In 2021, ProPublica published a series of articles based on tax information from thousands of wealthy Americans, prompting investigations into how the confidential data became public. The Treasury Inspector General for Tax Administration launched inquiries into potential breaches of taxpayer confidentiality.
The timing of Trump’s lawsuit coincides with his ongoing campaign for the 2024 Republican presidential nomination, where he remains the frontrunner despite facing multiple criminal indictments in separate cases.
Legal experts suggest the lawsuit faces significant hurdles. “While taxpayer information is certainly protected, proving exactly who leaked the information and establishing a precise damage amount will be challenging,” said Elizabeth Maresca, former IRS attorney and current law professor at Fordham University. “The $10 billion figure would require substantial evidence of specific financial harm directly tied to the alleged disclosures.”
The lawsuit could also face procedural challenges under the Federal Tort Claims Act, which governs claims against federal agencies and typically requires administrative remedies before court action.
For American taxpayers, the case highlights tensions between public interest in transparency regarding political leaders’ finances and legal protections for taxpayer privacy. Critics of Trump have long argued that presidents should voluntarily disclose tax information, while his supporters view the alleged leaks as politically motivated violations of privacy law.
The Trump team has indicated they will pursue the case aggressively, framing it as part of a pattern of government overreach against the former president. Meanwhile, neither the IRS nor the Treasury Department has issued official responses to the lawsuit’s allegations.
This legal action adds to Trump’s extensive portfolio of ongoing litigation as both plaintiff and defendant across multiple jurisdictions nationwide.
Fact Checker
Verify the accuracy of this article using The Disinformation Commission analysis and real-time sources.
13 Comments
Lawsuits and counter-lawsuits seem to be the modus operandi for Trump when it comes to his financial records. The public deserves answers, but the legal process often gets bogged down in technicalities. I hope this case can move forward in a constructive manner.
This lawsuit seems like a predictable move from Trump, who has long resisted scrutiny of his financial affairs. While the details of the alleged leaks are important, the broader issue of transparency for public officials remains critical for a functioning democracy.
I agree that transparency is vital, but the legal process around taxpayer privacy must also be respected. This case will likely become another partisan battleground, when the focus should be on ensuring appropriate safeguards and oversight for all public officials.
Trump’s history of fighting disclosure of his tax returns raises suspicions about what might be in them. While protecting taxpayer privacy is important, the public interest in understanding the finances of elected officials should take precedence in my view.
While I understand Trump’s desire to protect his privacy, the public interest in scrutinizing the financial affairs of elected officials outweighs that in my view. The IRS must ensure all taxpayer information is secured, but leaks like this can serve an important democratic purpose.
That’s a fair perspective. Striking the right balance between privacy and transparency is always challenging, especially for public figures. This lawsuit will likely become another polarized political battle rather than focusing on the substantive issues.
Given Trump’s history of fighting disclosure of his tax returns, this lawsuit feels more like a political stunt than a serious legal case. The American people should be able to scrutinize the finances of their elected leaders, within reasonable privacy protections.
I agree that transparency around the finances of public officials is critical. However, the specific legal issues here regarding taxpayer privacy and IRS disclosures also deserve careful consideration, regardless of one’s views on Trump.
This lawsuit is yet another chapter in the long-running saga of Trump’s efforts to shield his tax returns from public scrutiny. While I respect privacy concerns, the American people deserve transparency from their leaders, especially on financial matters. I hope this case is resolved fairly.
I agree that transparency is essential for public trust in government. However, the legal framework around taxpayer confidentiality is also important to uphold. This case will likely hinge on the specific details and circumstances of the alleged leaks.
Suing the IRS for $10 billion over tax return leaks seems like an excessive and disproportionate response, even for Trump. While protecting taxpayer privacy is important, the public interest in understanding the financial dealings of a former president outweighs that in my opinion.
This lawsuit seems like a heavy-handed attempt by Trump to deflect attention from the substance of the tax return leaks. Regardless of the legalities, the public has a right to know if the former president engaged in any improper financial dealings.
I agree that the substance of the leaked information is more important than the legal process. However, unauthorized disclosure of taxpayer data is still a serious violation that should be investigated and addressed properly.