Listen to the article
Senator Fetterman Calls for DHS Secretary Noem’s Dismissal Following Minnesota Operation
Democratic Senator John Fetterman of Pennsylvania has publicly called on President Donald Trump to dismiss Department of Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem, citing a failure to uphold the department’s core mission following controversial immigration enforcement actions in Minnesota.
In a direct appeal posted on the social media platform X on Tuesday, Fetterman tagged both the official presidential accounts and Trump’s personal account, writing: “I make a direct appeal to immediately fire @Sec_Noem.” The senator emphasized the severity of recent events, stating, “Americans have died. She is betraying DHS’s core mission and trashing your border security legacy.”
Fetterman’s unusually sharp criticism follows fatal incidents during recent immigration enforcement operations in Minnesota. The shootings of U.S. citizens Alex Pretti and Renee Good during DHS operations have sparked nationwide controversy and calls for accountability.
“Ms. Good and Mr. Pretti should still be alive. My family grieves for theirs,” Fetterman said in a separate statement released Monday. The senator urged an immediate halt to the operations in Minneapolis, describing the situation as “an ungovernable and dangerous urban theatre for civilians and law enforcement that is incompatible with the American spirit.”
The White House has not yet responded to requests for comment on Fetterman’s call for Noem’s removal.
Fetterman’s position is particularly notable given his reputation as one of the more moderate Democratic voices on immigration issues. Unlike many in his party, he has consistently opposed calls to abolish Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) and has advocated for a balanced approach to immigration policy.
“As a very pro-immigration Democrat and Ranking Member of the Subcommittee on Border Management, I believe our nation deserves a secured border and that we should deport all criminal migrants. I also believe there needs to be a path to citizenship for those hardworking families who are here,” Fetterman explained in his Monday statement.
He clarified his position further, saying, “I reject the calls to defund or abolish ICE. I strongly disagree with many strategies and practices ICE deployed in Minneapolis, and believe that must change.”
The senator’s criticism of Noem comes as more than half of House Democrats have reportedly backed an impeachment push against the DHS Secretary. The growing opposition to Noem’s leadership reflects broader concerns about the Trump administration’s aggressive immigration enforcement policies.
The Minnesota operations represent part of a nationwide crackdown on undocumented immigrants that has intensified under the current administration. While Trump campaigned heavily on stronger border security and immigration enforcement, the deaths of American citizens during these operations have raised serious questions about implementation and oversight.
Fetterman’s warning to Trump not to “make the mistake President Biden made for not firing a grossly incompetent DHS Secretary” signals a political calculation on his part, acknowledging Trump’s critical stance toward Biden’s border policies while attempting to position himself as a reasonable voice on immigration enforcement.
The controversy highlights the ongoing tensions in America’s immigration debate, with both parties struggling to find common ground between humanitarian concerns and security priorities. As federal authorities continue their nationwide immigration enforcement operations, calls for accountability and reform of tactics are likely to intensify, particularly if civilian casualties continue.
The White House now faces increasing pressure to address both the specific incidents in Minnesota and broader questions about DHS leadership and immigration enforcement strategies under Secretary Noem’s direction.
Fact Checker
Verify the accuracy of this article using The Disinformation Commission analysis and real-time sources.
14 Comments
I’m curious to learn more about the details of the DHS operations in Minnesota and what led to these tragic shootings. Transparency from the government is essential in a case like this.
Agreed, we need a full accounting of the events to understand what went wrong and how to prevent such outcomes in the future.
This is a tragic and sensitive situation. I encourage all parties to approach it with care, objectivity and a focus on finding the truth and ensuring justice for the victims.
Agreed. Politicizing this will only make it harder to get to the bottom of what happened and prevent similar incidents in the future.
Senator Fetterman is right to demand action. Losing innocent American lives during DHS operations is unacceptable. The Secretary must be held responsible.
Absolutely. There need to be clear consequences when government agencies fail in their duty to protect citizens.
The loss of innocent life is always heartbreaking. I hope the investigations into this incident are thorough and lead to meaningful reforms to protect citizens during government operations.
Well said. Upholding public safety and trust in government institutions should be the top priorities here.
This is a complex issue with political tensions, but the priority should be finding the facts and ensuring such incidents don’t happen again. The victims’ families deserve answers.
Well said. This transcends partisan politics – it’s about upholding the rule of law and basic human rights.
While the politics are complex, the fundamental issue is that innocent lives were lost. I hope the investigations are thorough and lead to reforms that protect public safety.
Well said. At the end of the day, this is about honoring the victims and ensuring the government upholds its duty to the people.
This is a serious situation that requires a thorough investigation. I hope the details will be made public so we can understand what happened and ensure proper accountability.
Agree, transparency and accountability are critical when there are tragic outcomes from government operations.