Listen to the article
Trust in American institutions, including the media, has hit a troubling low, with younger generations showing particularly high levels of skepticism toward news sources, according to recent research.
Just over one-third of Americans now believe people are generally trustworthy, reflecting a consistent decline over the past two decades, Pew Research Center reports. This eroding trust extends to foundational institutions like schools, courts, and government, with Gallup polls showing confidence in these pillars at historic lows.
Media organizations face especially steep challenges in rebuilding credibility with young audiences. A survey by SmartNews, a news curation app, found that 65% of Generation Z readers regularly question the accuracy of news content—a higher percentage than any other age group.
More concerning still, the News Literacy Project recently discovered that four out of five teenagers believe journalists fail to produce more trustworthy information than other content creators. Nearly 70% think journalists intentionally introduce bias into their reporting, while 45% believe journalists do more harm than good for democracy.
“The results are both a warning and a call to action,” media literacy experts point out. “Today’s young people are deeply skeptical, but they also crave trustworthy information.”
While some skepticism promotes critical thinking and helps readers avoid misinformation, experts warn that unchecked doubt can transform into cynicism, disconnecting young people from shared facts necessary for civic engagement. When everything is met with disbelief, they risk complete disengagement from current affairs and democratic processes.
The dangers are significant. As trust breaks down, misinformation thrives. Conspiracy theories and false information spread quickly through social media platforms, and research shows many teens believe the conspiracy theories they encounter online. Alarmingly, SmartNews found that only 13% of Gen Z report fact-checking what they read, making them the least likely generation to verify information.
The current environment makes distinguishing between credible journalism and misinformation increasingly difficult. Clickbait headlines, social media algorithms that amplify divisive content, and the rise of artificial intelligence have created a complex information landscape that even digital natives struggle to navigate effectively.
“This doesn’t mean Gen Z doesn’t care about the truth,” education researchers note. “Quite the opposite—they care deeply but feel overwhelmed by the sheer volume of noise.”
Encouragingly, schools nationwide are developing programs to address this challenge. In New York’s North Salem Central School District, a school librarian has guided students in creating Instagram reels that explain how to differentiate news from advertisements, identify AI-generated images, and fact-check claims using reliable sources.
California’s Woodland Hills Academy offers a dedicated current events elective focused on media literacy skills, while Illinois educators are integrating news literacy across various subjects, from examining hip-hop music history to evaluating scientific sources.
The impact appears promising. Teens who receive formal media literacy instruction demonstrate higher trust in legitimate news sources compared to peers without such education. This educational movement has gained traction nationally, with at least 18 states passing legislation requiring or promoting media literacy education. Connecticut, Illinois, and New Jersey have specifically mandated news literacy instruction in their curricula.
Education experts recommend five fundamental practices for helping students identify trustworthy sources: conducting basic research on news outlets; looking for evidence of journalistic standards; checking for transparency about reporting practices and funding; examining how publications handle corrections; and evaluating multiple articles to assess consistency and credibility.
“In today’s information ecosystem, skepticism is essential—but cynicism is corrosive,” media literacy advocates emphasize. “When young people are equipped with both the tools and trusted platforms to think critically, they’re better able to shape their world with facts, not fear.”
As information sources continue to proliferate and technologies for creating misleading content advance, the challenge of rebuilding trust while maintaining healthy skepticism remains central to preserving an informed citizenry—a cornerstone requirement for functional democracy.
Fact Checker
Verify the accuracy of this article using The Disinformation Commission analysis and real-time sources.
12 Comments
The findings underscore the challenges facing journalism today. Rebuilding trust will require a multi-faceted approach, including a renewed focus on ethical reporting, fact-checking, and addressing biases.
Engaging younger audiences and addressing their specific concerns will be crucial to the industry’s long-term viability.
While the statistics are alarming, this could also present an opportunity for media outlets to innovate and adapt to the needs of Gen Z. Embracing transparency and accountability may be the path forward.
Improving media literacy education could empower young people to critically evaluate news sources and combat misinformation.
Rebuilding trust in journalism is crucial, especially among younger generations. Gen Z’s skepticism highlights the need for media outlets to prioritize transparency, accuracy, and ethical reporting standards.
Addressing biased or sensationalized coverage will be key to regaining credibility with this demographic.
The findings highlight the need for the media industry to reflect on its practices and adapt to the changing information landscape. Regaining the trust of younger audiences should be a top priority.
Promoting diverse perspectives and amplifying underrepresented voices may help build more inclusive and trusted news coverage.
It’s concerning to see declining trust in core institutions like the media, schools, and government. Restoring faith in these pillars of society should be a top priority.
Improving media literacy and critical thinking skills among young people could help them navigate the information landscape more effectively.
The erosion of trust in institutions is a complex issue, but the media’s role in restoring faith is crucial. Rebuilding credibility with younger generations will be a significant challenge.
Collaboration between media, education, and technology sectors could help develop effective solutions to address this pressing problem.