Listen to the article
In a concerning development for parents and caregivers, Consumer Reports has issued an urgent warning about the proliferation of dangerous misinformation regarding infant sleep practices across social media platforms and e-commerce sites.
The consumer advocacy organization’s investigation revealed alarming trends in content that directly contradicts established medical guidance on safe sleep environments for babies. This misinformation appears prominently on platforms like Instagram, TikTok, and Facebook, as well as major online retailers including Amazon and Etsy.
Most troubling among the findings was the promotion of products and practices known to increase the risk of Sudden Infant Death Syndrome (SIDS) and other sleep-related fatalities. These include padded crib bumpers, inclined sleepers, and loose bedding—all items that have been linked to infant suffocation deaths and are explicitly advised against by pediatricians.
Dr. Ben Hoffman, chair of the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) Council on Injury, Violence and Poison Prevention, expressed serious concern about the investigation’s findings. “The proliferation of unsafe sleep information and products is deeply troubling,” he stated. “These recommendations exist because they save lives, not as optional guidelines.”
The AAP’s safe sleep recommendations are clear and evidence-based: infants should sleep alone on a firm, flat surface with no additional items in the sleep area. The organization emphasizes that babies should be placed on their backs in a crib, bassinet, or play yard that meets current safety standards, with only a fitted sheet—no pillows, blankets, stuffed animals, or crib bumpers.
Yet Consumer Reports found numerous social media accounts and online listings promoting precisely these dangerous items. In many cases, the products were marketed with appealing aesthetics or claims of improved sleep, directly targeting sleep-deprived parents desperate for solutions.
The report comes at a critical time, as approximately 3,400 infants die annually in the United States from sleep-related causes, including SIDS, accidental suffocation, and strangulation in bed. Many of these tragedies could be prevented with adherence to safe sleep guidelines.
Oriene Shin, policy counsel for Consumer Reports, highlighted the responsibility of tech companies and online retailers in the spread of this misinformation. “These platforms have the technology and resources to identify and remove dangerous content, yet harmful recommendations continue to flourish,” Shin noted. “When profit motives outweigh safety concerns, vulnerable consumers—in this case, babies—are put at serious risk.”
The investigation also revealed a concerning gap in regulatory oversight. While the Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) has banned certain dangerous infant sleep products, including inclined sleepers and crib bumpers, enforcement remains challenging in the vast digital marketplace.
In response to the findings, Consumer Reports has called for stricter content moderation policies across social platforms and e-commerce sites. The organization is also urging the Federal Trade Commission to investigate deceptive marketing practices that suggest unsafe products improve infant sleep or safety.
For parents and caregivers navigating this misleading information landscape, experts recommend consulting trusted sources like pediatricians and the AAP website for guidance on safe sleep practices. They emphasize that despite aesthetic trends or well-meaning advice from influencers, the science on infant sleep safety remains clear.
“What looks cute on social media can be deadly in practice,” warned Dr. Rachel Moon, lead author of the AAP’s safe sleep guidelines. “The safest sleep environment is one that follows the bare is best principle—just the baby on a firm mattress with nothing else.”
As the holiday season approaches—a time when many families purchase items for infants—Consumer Reports stresses the importance of prioritizing safety over trends, and encourages gift-givers to consider consulting with parents about appropriate items that align with safe sleep recommendations.
Fact Checker
Verify the accuracy of this article using The Disinformation Commission analysis and real-time sources.
12 Comments
This is a really serious issue that requires urgent action. Infant safety should be the top priority, not profits from risky products. Social media platforms and retailers need to do more to protect vulnerable families.
As a pediatrician, I’m deeply concerned by these findings. Misinformation about safe sleep can have tragic consequences. We need to do more to ensure families have access to reliable, evidence-based guidance.
Absolutely. The American Academy of Pediatrics has clear recommendations on safe sleep that all parents and caregivers should be aware of. Combating dangerous misinformation is crucial.
Disturbing to see the promotion of unsafe infant sleep products and practices. Glad Consumer Reports is working to combat this and get the facts out there for parents. Safety has to be the top priority.
As a new parent, I’m alarmed to hear about this issue. It’s so important that we can trust the information we find online. Kudos to Consumer Reports for investigating and bringing this to light.
Completely agree. With SIDS being such a serious risk, we need to make sure parents have the facts to keep their babies safe. Misinformation can have devastating consequences.
This is a really important issue that deserves more attention. While social media makes it easy to share content, there need to be stronger safeguards against the spread of dangerous misinformation.
Exactly. Platforms have a responsibility to monitor and remove content that contradicts established medical guidance, especially when it comes to protecting vulnerable infants. Kudos to Consumer Reports for shining a light on this.
It’s so concerning to see the proliferation of unsafe sleep information and products online. As a new parent, I rely on trusted sources like the AAP for guidance. Kudos to Consumer Reports for shining a light on this problem.
I agree completely. Easy access to misinformation on social media and e-commerce sites is putting babies at risk. We need stronger regulation and enforcement to ensure families have the facts to keep their children safe.
This is really concerning. Spreading misinformation about safe infant sleep practices can have devastating consequences. Glad to see Consumer Reports taking action to warn parents and caregivers.
Absolutely. It’s critical that families have access to reliable, evidence-based information on safe sleep for babies. Social media and online retailers need to do more to curb the spread of dangerous content.