Listen to the article
As the new year begins, many people consider adopting early-rising habits as part of self-improvement routines. However, sleep experts caution that forcing yourself to wake up early may not benefit everyone equally and could potentially harm your health depending on your natural sleep tendencies.
Sleep specialists are increasingly challenging the notion that early risers are inherently more productive or healthier. Research indicates that individuals have genetically predetermined sleep patterns that significantly influence when their bodies naturally want to rest and wake.
“We need to move beyond the ‘early bird gets the worm’ sayings and consider the biological cost of fighting one’s internal clock,” said Dr. Aaron Pinkhasov, chair of the Department of Psychiatry at NYU Grossman Long Island School of Medicine.
Sleep science reveals that people cycle through different sleep phases every 90 to 110 minutes, alternating between deep non-REM sleep and REM sleep. The early portions of night sleep feature more deep sleep, which supports physical recovery, immune function and memory consolidation. Later cycles contain more REM sleep, critical for learning, emotional processing and optimal brain function.
Whether someone is naturally inclined to rise early or late depends on their “chronotype” – essentially whether they’re a “morning bird” or a “night owl.” According to Pinkhasov, this sleep-wake preference is largely inherited, with approximately 40-50% of this pattern being genetically determined.
“Morning birds” typically fall asleep earlier and achieve deep sleep earlier in their sleep cycles. They often wake feeling more naturally alert. In contrast, “night owls” experience their deepest and most restorative REM sleep in the later hours of their sleep period and early morning. Forcing night owls to wake earlier than their bodies are programmed for can disrupt these crucial REM cycles.
This mismatch between natural sleep patterns and imposed wake times can lead to what Pinkhasov describes as “wired but tired” fatigue, characterized by mood instability and potential long-term metabolic consequences.
Dr. Nissa Keyashian, a California board-certified psychiatrist and author of “Practicing Stillness,” noted the broader health implications for those whose natural rhythms don’t align with typical societal schedules.
“Unfortunately, because a lot of people have early work, family or social commitments, night owls have a higher prevalence of anxiety, depression, eating disorders, obesity, obstructive sleep apnea and type 2 diabetes,” Keyashian explained.
The primary benefit of adopting an earlier schedule is better alignment with society’s predominant 9-to-5 structure. However, experts emphasize that consistency and sleep quality should take precedence over arbitrary early-morning goals. Forcing a significant shift against one’s natural chronotype can have substantial negative health impacts.
For those who need or want to adjust their sleep patterns, experts recommend several evidence-based strategies. Maintaining consistent bedtimes and wake times – even on weekends – helps regulate the body’s internal clock. Establishing a relaxing pre-sleep routine that minimizes electronics and includes calming activities like meditation, aromatherapy, warm showers, or herbal tea can prepare the body for rest.
Rather than dramatic changes, Keyashian suggests incrementally adjusting wake times by just 15 minutes per day. Exposure to bright light in the morning has also been shown to improve mood, energy levels and concentration – particularly important for those experiencing seasonal mood changes during winter months.
Some individuals may also benefit from minimizing caffeine intake and being mindful about evening exercise, which can interfere with falling asleep for certain people.
The experts’ consensus points toward prioritizing sleep patterns that honor individual biological rhythms rather than forcing conformity to arbitrary standards of early rising. This personalized approach to sleep hygiene recognizes that optimal productivity and health depend on working with – not against – one’s inherent chronotype.
Understanding your natural sleep patterns and making adjustments that respect your body’s needs may ultimately prove more beneficial than adhering to the popular but potentially misguided notion that productivity requires early mornings.
Fact Checker
Verify the accuracy of this article using The Disinformation Commission analysis and real-time sources.
12 Comments
The insight about the different sleep cycles and the importance of REM sleep is fascinating. It really highlights how complex our sleep needs are. Trying to impose a rigid early-rising schedule may do more harm than good for many people.
Absolutely, the sleep research paints a much more nuanced picture than the simplistic ‘early bird’ narrative. Understanding the importance of our natural circadian rhythms is key to optimizing health and performance.
This is a timely reminder that we shouldn’t be too quick to judge or shame people for their sleep habits. As the research shows, our internal clocks play a major role in our health and productivity. Respecting individual differences is key.
Well said. Forcing ourselves to go against our natural sleep patterns can come with real consequences. Finding the right balance and rhythm for our unique biology should be the goal, not subscribing to a one-size-fits-all ‘early is better’ mentality.
Interesting perspective. While early rising may work for some, the research indicates our natural sleep cycles play a significant role in health and productivity. Forcing ourselves to fight our internal clocks could come with real biological costs.
Absolutely, we should respect our individual sleep patterns rather than blindly buying into the ‘early bird’ narrative. Tailoring our routines to our natural circadian rhythms seems key for optimal health and performance.
This is a fascinating and important topic. The research highlighting the role of our natural sleep cycles and the different sleep stages is eye-opening. We shouldn’t be so quick to judge people’s sleep habits – finding the right balance for our individual biology is key.
Well said. Forcing ourselves to go against our natural circadian rhythms can come with real health consequences. Tailoring our routines to our unique sleep needs is a much more effective approach than blindly subscribing to the ‘early is better’ mentality.
I’m glad to see sleep experts pushing back on the idea that early risers are inherently more productive or healthier. Our sleep cycles are deeply tied to our biology, and trying to fight that can come with real costs. This is an important message.
Agreed, we need to be more open-minded and less judgmental about different sleep preferences. Respecting individual differences in our natural sleep patterns is crucial for overall wellbeing and performance.
I’m glad to see sleep experts challenging the notion that early risers are inherently superior. Our sleep cycles are deeply tied to our biology and trying to overrule them may be counterproductive. This is an important nuance to consider.
Exactly, one-size-fits-all sleep advice doesn’t work. We need to listen to our bodies and find the schedule that allows us to function at our best, whether that’s early morning or night owl tendencies.