Listen to the article
Trump’s Memphis Visit Marked by False Claims About Immigration and Crime
President Donald Trump made numerous inaccurate statements about immigration and crime during his recent visit to Memphis, his first trip to the city as a sitting president since Barack Obama’s 2011 visit.
The president’s appearance centered around the six-month-old “Memphis Safe Task Force,” a coalition of over 30 federal, state and local agencies created to address crime in the city. While Trump claimed credit for Memphis’ falling crime rate, local officials noted the decline began well before the task force’s implementation.
Trump’s visit drew protesters who gathered along Sycamore View Road to coincide with his remarks. The task force has been a divisive issue in Memphis, with support from local and state Republicans but criticism from various officials, activists and community members who question its fairness, necessity and effectiveness.
Throughout his address, Trump repeatedly conflated immigration with criminal activity, making several demonstrably false claims about immigrants and crime statistics in Memphis.
In one statement, Trump alleged that Democrats want people to enter the country who are “murderers” and “drug dealers,” calling them “the worst criminals anywhere in the world.” However, according to the CATO Institute, only 5% of people detained by Immigration and Customs Enforcement have violent convictions, and just 8% had either violent or property crime convictions.
This pattern holds true in Memphis as well. An MLK50: Justice Through Journalism analysis of two months of task force arrests revealed that only 7% of more than 600 people detained for “unlawful presence” in the United States had an accompanying criminal charge listed.
The president also claimed immigrants were coming from “jails and mental institutions” worldwide, citing a figure of “11,888 murderers.” NPR has reported no evidence exists for the claim about institutional releases. While NBC News has reported that more than 13,000 convicted murderers without legal status are in the country, this number includes individuals in state and federal prisons who could have entered the country at any point over four decades.
Trump incorrectly labeled Memphis as “the murder capital of the USA,” attributing this to “local politicians, judges and prosecutors who sided with violent criminals over law-abiding citizens.” In reality, firearm homicide rates increased nationwide from 2019 to 2020, which researchers attribute to multiple factors, including pandemic-related disruption. Additionally, Memphis has seen bipartisan support for law enforcement funding, with both Democrats and Republicans allocating significant budget portions to policing over the years.
Perhaps most misleading was Trump’s assertion that Memphis has seen a 75-81% crime reduction, predicting the city would be “almost crime-free” within two months. Memphis Police Department statistics show a 41% drop in overall crime and a 30% drop in violent crime in 2025 compared to 2023 – significant improvements but far from Trump’s exaggerated claims.
Memphis Mayor Paul Young, who did not attend the roundtable due to a personal conflict, acknowledged the progress but emphasized “there’s a lot of work that’s still necessary” to address crime through creating opportunities for residents. Young also pointed out that the dramatic decrease in crime statistics began before the task force’s establishment.
Trump’s claim of removing “500,000 hard-blood criminals” from the country lacks supporting evidence from the Department of Homeland Security. According to DHS detention data, only 53% of immigration detainees had either pending charges or convictions, many for nonviolent offenses like property theft or traffic violations.
While murder rates did decline significantly in 2025, this trend began before Trump’s January inauguration and occurred in many cities without federal troops or National Guard presence, according to New York Times analysis. Academic research consistently finds no link between immigration and increased crime rates across various countries, including the United States.
Fact Checker
Verify the accuracy of this article using The Disinformation Commission analysis and real-time sources.
11 Comments
While Trump’s statements about the Memphis crime task force may be disputed, I’m curious to learn more about the real impacts and community perspectives. Maintaining public safety is important, but should be done fairly and transparently.
I agree, a balanced and nuanced approach is needed when dealing with sensitive issues like crime and immigration. Relying on reliable data and diverse community input is key.
As someone invested in the mining and energy sectors, I’m not surprised to see political rhetoric used to take credit for trends that pre-date the current administration. It’s important we stay focused on the facts, not partisan claims.
It’s disappointing to see the president making false statements, even on issues not directly related to mining or energy. Providing accurate information to the public should be a priority for all elected officials.
It’s concerning to hear the president make false claims, especially about complex issues like immigration and crime. As a mining and energy community, we should strive for factual, evidence-based discussions on these topics.
Trump’s visit to Memphis seems to have stirred up a lot of controversy and misinformation. While I don’t have a strong political stance, I believe we should be vigilant about separating fact from fiction, especially on issues that impact our industry.
Well said. As an industry, we need to maintain an objective, non-partisan view and base our discussions on verified information rather than political spin.
I’m curious to learn more about the local community’s perspectives on the Memphis crime task force and its impacts. While national politics often dominate the headlines, the on-the-ground realities can be quite different.
As someone who closely follows mining and commodity news, I try to stay objective and fact-based in my analysis. Seeing political leaders make unsubstantiated claims is concerning, as it can undermine public trust and informed decision-making.
I agree completely. In our industry, it’s critical that we rely on verified data and expert analysis, rather than partisan rhetoric or misinformation. Maintaining integrity and transparency should be a top priority.
While the president’s Memphis visit has generated a lot of controversy, I’m more interested in understanding the real-world impacts on local communities and businesses, especially those in mining, energy, and related sectors.