Listen to the article
ICE Arrest in Massachusetts Sparks Controversy Amid Conflicting Accounts
A heated controversy has erupted following a viral video showing a chaotic immigration arrest in Fitchburg, Massachusetts. The footage captured a scene where a man appeared to lose consciousness while holding a child as US Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) officers attempted to detain a woman in their vehicle last Thursday.
The dramatic video, first obtained by the Boston Globe, shows a woman frantically trying to rouse the unresponsive man in the driver’s seat as a crying child sits between them. Bystanders can be heard shouting “He’s having a seizure,” while ICE agents attempt to remove the passengers from the vehicle and repeatedly order onlookers to “back up.” One witness is heard claiming, “They’re trying to rip the baby out of his hand.”
The Department of Homeland Security (DHS) has pushed back strongly against the narrative surrounding the video, calling it “misleading” and incomplete. In a statement released Friday, DHS officials identified the woman being arrested as Juliana Milena Ojeda-Montoya, a 26-year-old Ecuadorian national they described as an undocumented immigrant with a pending criminal case.
According to DHS, Ojeda-Montoya is accused of “repeatedly stabbing a coworker with scissors and then throwing a trash can at her victim” in an August incident. This information, they claim, provides critical context missing from the viral footage that has circulated online.
DHS explained that ICE officers were conducting a “targeted operation” to arrest Ojeda-Montoya when the incident occurred. Her husband, Carlos Zapata Rivera, and their young child were in the vehicle at the time of the arrest. The agency noted that the child was sitting on the mother’s lap rather than in a proper car seat.
The sequence of events, as described by DHS, differs significantly from what some observers initially interpreted from the video. Officials claim that when officers informed Ojeda-Montoya of the arrest warrant, they requested she hand over the child to her husband. According to DHS, she refused until Zapata Rivera “pretended to have a medical episode.”
DHS officials said ICE agents immediately called 911, but when emergency responders arrived, they found “no legitimate medical concerns.” The agency added that Zapata Rivera declined medical treatment and was observed to be “coherent and on his feet moments later.”
Assistant Secretary Tricia McLaughlin accused media outlets of spreading a “FALSE narrative about our brave ICE law enforcement officers.” She stated, “As usual, here’s the REAL story: ICE targeted a known criminal who repeatedly stabbed her coworker. Medical personnel found there was no legitimate medical emergency.”
McLaughlin further claimed that both parents initially told officers they were willing to let the child be placed in state custody. However, Zapata Rivera ultimately left with the child after allegedly realizing he could face immigration charges if he refused, according to the DHS statement.
During the confrontation, DHS claimed a “crowd of agitators” gathered and shouted obscenities, threats, and even antisemitic remarks at the ICE officers, further complicating an already tense situation.
Additional background provided by DHS indicates that both Ojeda-Montoya and Zapata Rivera were apprehended by US Border Patrol near Lukeville, Arizona, in February 2023. They were subsequently released into the United States the following month under Biden administration policies. Following her arrest in Massachusetts, Ojeda-Montoya was transferred to Cumberland County Jail in Maine, where she will remain in ICE custody pending removal proceedings.
The incident highlights ongoing tensions surrounding immigration enforcement actions in communities across the United States, with law enforcement accounts often conflicting with witness descriptions of such operations. The controversy comes amid heightened national debate about immigration policies and enforcement priorities as the Biden administration transitions to the incoming Trump administration.
Fact Checker
Verify the accuracy of this article using The Disinformation Commission analysis and real-time sources.
9 Comments
While the video is concerning, it’s important to reserve judgment until the facts are clear. Immigration enforcement is a sensitive issue, and finding the right approach to balance security and civil liberties is an ongoing challenge.
Agreed. Maintaining public trust in institutions like ICE is critical, even when dealing with complex and emotionally-charged situations. Transparency and accountability should be the priority moving forward.
This is a troubling incident that deserves a thorough investigation. Both the public and law enforcement have a responsibility to approach such sensitive situations with care and restraint, focusing on facts over rhetoric.
This is a concerning incident. We need to hear all the facts before rushing to judgment. I hope the man receives proper medical attention and that the situation is resolved safely for all involved.
Agreed, details are still unclear. Both the public and law enforcement have a responsibility to handle sensitive situations like this with care and restraint.
This is a troubling video, but we should withhold conclusions until the full context is known. Protecting public safety while respecting individual rights is a delicate balance that merits careful consideration.
Well said. These types of incidents highlight the need for ongoing training and review of policies to ensure the humane treatment of all individuals, regardless of immigration status.
Immigration enforcement is a complex and often emotional issue. I’m interested to see how the facts unfold and whether any changes to procedures could help prevent similar incidents in the future.
Absolutely. Maintaining public trust in law enforcement is critical, even when dealing with difficult situations. Transparency and accountability will be key here.