Listen to the article
Five Florida ophthalmology clinics have reached settlements with the federal government totaling nearly $6 million to resolve allegations of filing false claims to Medicare and Medicaid programs. The settlement addresses accusations that the clinics billed for eye procedures that were deemed medically unnecessary.
The agreement, finalized this week, comes after a lengthy investigation by the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services’ Office of Inspector General, working in conjunction with the Department of Justice. Federal prosecutors alleged that between 2018 and 2023, the clinics systematically billed federal healthcare programs for procedures that patients did not require, violating the False Claims Act.
“This settlement underscores our commitment to protecting federal healthcare dollars and ensuring patient care decisions are based on medical necessity, not financial gain,” said U.S. Attorney Maria Rodriguez, who led the prosecution. “Healthcare providers who prioritize profits over appropriate patient care will be held accountable.”
The five clinics, located across central and south Florida, include Sunshine Eye Institute in Tampa, Gulf Coast Vision Center in Naples, Atlantic Ophthalmology Associates in Miami, Lakeland Retina Specialists, and Orlando Eye Partners. The settlements range from $850,000 to $1.7 million per clinic, reflecting the varying extent of alleged improper billing practices at each facility.
According to court documents, the clinics routinely performed and billed for procedures including intravitreal injections, laser treatments, and certain diagnostic tests when patient conditions did not warrant such interventions. In some cases, the frequency of these procedures exceeded established medical guidelines.
The whistleblower complaint that initiated the investigation was filed by Dr. James Hernandez, a former ophthalmologist at one of the clinics, under the qui tam provisions of the False Claims Act. Dr. Hernandez will receive approximately $1.1 million as his share of the recovery.
The settlement highlights a growing trend of enforcement actions targeting specialty medical practices. In 2025 alone, the Department of Justice has recovered more than $1.2 billion from healthcare fraud settlements, with ophthalmology emerging as a particular focus for investigators.
“Ophthalmology has become a hotspot for compliance issues,” explained Sarah Jenkins, a healthcare compliance attorney with Bryant & Wilson. “The high reimbursement rates for certain eye procedures, combined with the largely elderly patient population, creates an environment where billing abuse can occur if proper compliance protocols aren’t maintained.”
None of the clinics admitted wrongdoing as part of the settlement agreements, which is typical in such cases. However, each clinic has agreed to enter into a five-year corporate integrity agreement with the HHS Office of Inspector General, requiring enhanced compliance programs, regular external audits, and ongoing monitoring.
Dr. Robert Feldman, president of the Florida Ophthalmological Society, emphasized that the vast majority of eye care specialists adhere to proper billing practices. “These isolated cases shouldn’t overshadow the essential care that ophthalmologists provide to millions of Floridians each year,” Feldman stated. “However, our organization strongly supports accountability for any provider who violates billing standards.”
The settlements also reflect the Biden administration’s continued emphasis on healthcare fraud enforcement. The Department of Justice has recently expanded its Strike Force operations, which coordinate efforts between federal and state agencies to combat healthcare fraud.
For patients, the settlement raises questions about how to ensure they’re receiving appropriate care. Healthcare advocates recommend seeking second opinions for major procedures and asking providers to explain why specific treatments are necessary.
The clinics will pay the settlement amounts over the next three years, with initial payments due within 30 days. Additionally, the clinics must implement new billing review procedures and conduct staff training on proper documentation of medical necessity.
This case represents one of the largest ophthalmology fraud settlements in Florida history and signals continued scrutiny of specialty medical practices across the healthcare sector.
Fact Checker
Verify the accuracy of this article using The Disinformation Commission analysis and real-time sources.
16 Comments
Kudos to the Department of Justice and HHS for going after these clinics that prioritized profits over appropriate patient care. Holding healthcare providers accountable for fraud is crucial.
Absolutely, healthcare fraud can have serious consequences for patients. I’m glad to see the authorities taking strong action to protect vulnerable populations.
This settlement highlights the importance of oversight and accountability in the medical industry. Patients should be able to trust that their care is driven by medical necessity, not a clinic’s bottom line.
I agree, medical ethics and patient wellbeing need to come before financial interests. Kudos to the investigators for catching these fraudulent practices.
While the details are troubling, I’m glad the government was able to uncover and address this pattern of fraudulent billing practices. Protecting Medicare and Medicaid funds is crucial to ensuring quality care for vulnerable populations.
Yes, safeguarding taxpayer-funded healthcare programs is vital. This settlement shows the authorities are serious about cracking down on healthcare fraud and abuse.
It’s good to see the government taking action against these eye clinics that allegedly billed for unnecessary procedures. Protecting Medicare and Medicaid funds is vital to ensuring vulnerable populations have access to quality care.
Absolutely. Healthcare fraud can have serious consequences for patients and the integrity of our medical system. This settlement demonstrates the authorities’ commitment to holding providers accountable.
This case highlights the need for stronger oversight and accountability measures in the medical industry. Patients deserve to know their care is being driven by medical necessity, not a clinic’s bottom line.
Absolutely. It’s unacceptable for healthcare providers to prioritize profits over appropriate patient care. This settlement sends an important message that such fraudulent practices will not be tolerated.
It’s concerning to hear about these eye clinics allegedly billing for unnecessary procedures. Patients put their trust in medical professionals, who should always act with integrity. Hopefully this settlement sends a clear message.
Agreed, the public needs to be able to trust that their healthcare providers are acting in their best interests. This settlement is an important step in reinforcing those ethical standards.
While the details are troubling, I’m glad the authorities were able to uncover and address this pattern of fraudulent billing. Protecting federal healthcare funds is crucial to ensuring quality, affordable care for all.
Agreed. This settlement shows the government is serious about cracking down on healthcare fraud and abuse. Patients need to be able to trust that their care is driven by medical necessity, not financial gain.
Interesting that these eye clinics were caught billing Medicare and Medicaid for unnecessary procedures. It’s good to see the government taking action to protect healthcare funds and ensure patient care is the priority, not profits.
Absolutely, healthcare fraud can waste billions in taxpayer money. Glad the authorities were able to uncover and address this pattern of abuse.