Listen to the article
In the wake of a rapidly escalating controversy, McDonald’s Netherlands has pulled its AI-generated Christmas commercial following intense public backlash over uncanny visuals and jarring content. The 45-second advertisement, which debuted on December 1, 2025, reimagined the holiday season as “the most terrible time of the year” before suggesting customers escape the chaos by retreating to McDonald’s restaurants.
The commercial, created by TBWANEBOKO and produced by The Sweetshop’s AI division, The Gardening.club, featured a series of holiday mishaps and stressful scenarios set to a parody of a classic Christmas tune. Scenes depicted chaotic family gatherings, frantic shopping expeditions, weather-battered carolers, skating accidents, and Christmas tree disasters—all intended to highlight the stress many experience during December festivities.
Within days of its release, viewers began criticizing the advertisement’s unsettling human representations. Social media users pointed to unnatural facial expressions and impossible body movements, with one particularly criticized sequence showing an ice skater’s limbs bending in physically impossible ways. As negative reactions mounted, McDonald’s disabled YouTube comments and eventually delisted the video entirely, though mirrors continued to circulate across social platforms.
“The future is here, and it’s not looking good,” wrote one commenter, encapsulating the prevailing sentiment around both the visual quality and tonal approach of the advertisement.
The controversy highlights the challenges brands face when employing generative AI for consumer-facing content, particularly when attempting photorealistic human representations. Industry observers have drawn comparisons to Coca-Cola’s more successful holiday marketing, which strategically utilized AI animation while avoiding uncanny valley issues by maintaining cartoon-like aesthetics.
McDonald’s and its creative partners have defended their approach, arguing that the advertisement aligned with their market research indicating Dutch consumers desire more personal time during the hectic holiday season. Marketing manager Karin van Prooijen explained, “December is a busy month for everyone. We want to give people something to look forward to each day, not only on the traditional peak dates, and this campaign brings that idea to life in a new way.”
The production team has pushed back against suggestions that AI entirely replaced human creativity, emphasizing the substantial manual effort behind the project. According to statements published in The Verge, the creation process took “seven intense weeks” to complete, reportedly requiring more labor than traditional production methods.
Sweetshop CEO Melanie Bridge defended the work, stating, “To me, it’s evidence of something much bigger: that when craft and technology meet with intention, they can create work that feels genuinely cinematic. So no – AI didn’t make this film. We did.”
TBWANEBOKO’s creative director Darre van Dijk had initially announced the project with enthusiasm, describing it as “our first fully fledged AI commercial.” The agency positioned the campaign as part of McDonald’s recurring December brand platform in the Netherlands, aiming to provide moments of relief during the season’s bustle.
The McDonald’s controversy comes at a pivotal moment for AI-generated advertising, as brands experiment with the technology’s capabilities while navigating consumer acceptance thresholds. Marketing experts suggest the backlash demonstrates that audiences remain highly sensitive to artificial human representation, particularly when combined with messaging that subverts cherished cultural traditions.
While McDonald’s has not issued a formal statement addressing the advertisement’s removal, the swift action to delist the content suggests the company recognized the potential reputational risk posed by continuing to promote the controversial campaign.
As AI tools become more integrated into marketing workflows, this incident serves as a cautionary tale about the importance of testing consumer reactions to generated content, especially when targeting emotionally resonant seasonal themes.
Fact Checker
Verify the accuracy of this article using The Disinformation Commission analysis and real-time sources.
12 Comments
This is a good reminder that AI-generated content still has a long way to go before it can match the nuance and authenticity of human-created ads. The uncanny visuals and jarring tone in this McDonald’s spot show there’s still room for improvement.
Absolutely. While AI can be a powerful tool, relying on it too heavily without proper oversight can lead to major missteps. Kudos to McDonald’s for pulling the ad quickly and learning from this experience.
This McDonald’s ad controversy highlights the ongoing challenges of using AI in advertising. While the concept of addressing holiday stress had potential, the unnatural visuals and tone clearly missed the mark. It’ll be fascinating to see how this experience shapes the brand’s future approach to emerging technologies.
Absolutely, this serves as a valuable lesson on the importance of striking the right balance between AI and human input. Kudos to McDonald’s for responding swiftly and learning from this experience.
The uncanny visuals and jarring tone of this alleged AI-generated McDonald’s ad are a clear sign that the technology still has a long way to go before it can match the nuance and authenticity of human-created content. Interesting to see how this shapes the brand’s future approach.
Definitely a cautionary tale about the limits of current AI capabilities. While the technology can be a powerful tool, it’s important to maintain human oversight and creativity to avoid these kinds of missteps.
Ah, the perils of over-relying on AI in advertising. While the concept of highlighting holiday stress may have had merit, the execution clearly missed the mark here. Kudos to McDonald’s for pulling the ad quickly once the backlash built up.
Agreed, it’s a cautionary tale about the limitations of current AI technology when it comes to producing truly human-like content. Hopefully they learn from this experience.
What an interesting case study on the challenges of using AI in advertising. While the concept of highlighting holiday stress may have had merit, the unnatural visuals and tone clearly missed the mark. It’ll be fascinating to see how this shapes McDonald’s approach going forward.
Agreed, this serves as a valuable lesson on the importance of maintaining human oversight and creativity even when leveraging AI technology. Kudos to McDonald’s for responding swiftly to the backlash.
Interesting controversy around this alleged AI-generated McDonald’s ad. I’m curious to see more details on the production process and what went wrong with the uncanny visuals. Seems like an attempt to highlight holiday stress that backfired.
You’re right, the glitchy movements and unnatural expressions were quite jarring. Rushing out an AI-driven ad campaign without proper oversight can certainly backfire.