Listen to the article
Several social media users have recently shared a video they claim shows a missile attack on Israel during the ongoing conflict with Hamas. However, fact-checking reveals the footage is actually from May 2021 and depicts an earlier confrontation between Israel and Palestinian militants.
The video, which shows multiple rockets flying through the night sky over what appears to be an urban area, has garnered thousands of shares across platforms including Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram. The misleading posts emerged in the wake of Hamas’ surprise October 7 attack on Israel, which triggered the current military escalation in the region.
“This is happening right now in Israel. Pray for the innocent civilians caught in the crossfire,” reads one viral post accompanying the video, which has been shared over 5,000 times since last weekend.
Digital forensics experts were able to trace the origin of the footage through reverse image searches and metadata analysis. The video first appeared online during the May 2021 conflict, when Hamas and other militant groups in Gaza launched thousands of rockets toward Israeli cities, and Israel responded with airstrikes on Gaza.
“This is a clear example of how older content gets recycled during new conflicts,” explained Dr. Claire Wardle, a misinformation researcher at the Information Futures Lab. “During breaking news events, there’s an information vacuum that creates ideal conditions for old videos to resurface and be presented as current.”
The 11-day conflict in May 2021 resulted in over 250 deaths in Gaza and 13 in Israel before a ceasefire was reached. By contrast, the current conflict has already claimed more than 1,400 Israeli lives in the initial Hamas attack, while Gaza health authorities report over 6,500 Palestinian casualties from Israeli military operations.
Media verification specialists note several telltale signs that help identify the video as older footage. The lighting conditions, specific buildings visible in the background, and the trajectory patterns of the missiles match verified footage from the 2021 conflict. Additionally, the video quality and compression artifacts suggest it has been downloaded and re-uploaded multiple times over the past two years.
This isn’t the first instance of misinformation surrounding the current Israel-Hamas conflict. Fact-checkers worldwide have identified dozens of misleading videos, manipulated images, and false claims circulating online since hostilities erupted earlier this month.
Social media platforms have implemented various measures to combat the spread of such misinformation. Meta, the parent company of Facebook and Instagram, has expanded its fact-checking partnerships and deployed additional content reviewers focused on Middle East content. Twitter (now X) has faced criticism for reduced moderation capabilities following staff cuts under Elon Musk’s ownership.
The Israeli-Palestinian conflict has historically been a hotbed for misinformation, with emotional narratives and complex geopolitical dynamics making it particularly vulnerable to manipulation. Digital literacy experts emphasize the importance of verifying content before sharing, especially during active conflicts.
“Always check when and where a video originated before assuming it represents current events,” advises Melissa Fleming, Under-Secretary-General for Global Communications at the United Nations. “During conflicts, information itself becomes weaponized, and citizens need to be particularly vigilant.”
Media organizations including Reuters, Associated Press, and AFP maintain dedicated fact-checking operations that regularly debunk viral content related to global conflicts. These services have been working overtime to address the surge in misleading content about the Israel-Hamas war.
For those seeking reliable information about the ongoing conflict, experts recommend following established news organizations with correspondents on the ground, consulting multiple sources from different perspectives, and being wary of emotional appeals accompanying unverified footage.
As the conflict continues to unfold, the challenge of separating fact from fiction remains crucial for public understanding of events in Israel and Gaza, with misinformation experts warning that the volume of misleading content is likely to increase as the situation develops.
Fact Checker
Verify the accuracy of this article using The Disinformation Commission analysis and real-time sources.
6 Comments
This highlights the need for caution when consuming social media content related to geopolitical conflicts. Fact-checking and due diligence are essential to avoid amplifying false narratives. Kudos to the experts who traced the origins of this misleading video.
Exactly. In a highly charged environment, it’s all too easy for old or unrelated footage to be shared as current events. Responsible reporting and critical thinking are vital to cut through the noise.
The ongoing conflict in Israel/Gaza is a complex and sensitive issue. While the video may have been shared with good intentions, it’s concerning to see old footage being presented as current events. Fact-checking is crucial to avoid fueling misinformation.
Well said. Maintaining objectivity and verifying information sources is key, especially when reporting on geopolitical conflicts where emotions can run high. Kudos to the fact-checkers for setting the record straight on this misleading video.
Appreciate the fact-checking on this old footage. It’s important to verify claims and not spread misinformation, especially during ongoing conflicts. The situation in Israel/Gaza is complex, and clear reporting on the current events is crucial.
Agreed, verifying sources and combating the spread of misinformation is critical. This video is a good example of how old footage can be misleadingly repurposed to inflame tensions.