Listen to the article
Social media posts claiming that UK bank NatWest recently introduced a carbon footprint tracking feature linked to digital ID are misleading, as the optional service has been available to customers since 2021.
Multiple Facebook posts from October 2023 circulated screenshots of NatWest’s mobile banking app showing CO2 figures in kilograms next to transactions, with captions suggesting this was a new feature. One post claimed, “NatWest have updated their banking app so it will now monitor your carbon footprint based upon what you purchase. This will soon be tagged to your Digital I.D no doubt.”
Another post attempted to connect the feature to recent government initiatives, stating: “Nat west now has a carbon footprint tracker on their banking app…just as starmer is trying to bring out a digital id. Can see how it will all fit together with the digital currency tracking your carbon footprint with your purchases.”
These claims misrepresent both the timeline and purpose of the feature. NatWest actually announced the carbon footprint tracker in July 2021, launching it in November of that year in partnership with carbon-tracking firm CoGo. The timing contradicts suggestions that the feature is newly implemented or connected to recent digital ID initiatives.
A NatWest spokesperson clarified in an email statement: “The carbon tracker is an optional feature we launched in 2021. Customers choose to opt-in and can opt-out whenever they like.” The bank emphasized that no carbon footprint data is shared with the government and that “the carbon tracking feature is not related to digital ID.”
The confusion may stem from the British government’s September 26 announcement that digital identity documents would become mandatory for anyone wanting to prove their right to work in Britain. However, NatWest’s carbon tracker and the government’s digital ID initiative are entirely separate developments with no connection between them.
According to NatWest’s website, the tracker estimates emissions by matching anonymized outgoing transactions to spending categories and multiplying them by industry-specific emissions factors. This data remains anonymized and is not shared by CoGo with any entity other than the bank for the purpose of supporting the app feature.
The Department for Science, Innovation and Technology has previously addressed similar concerns, stating that while digital ID would be required for right to work checks, it would not be used to track “an individual’s carbon score.”
Environmental impact tracking tools have become increasingly common in the financial sector as banks respond to growing consumer interest in understanding the carbon footprint of their spending habits. Several major financial institutions have introduced similar features in recent years, positioning them as optional services for environmentally conscious customers rather than mandatory monitoring tools.
The spread of misinformation connecting NatWest’s carbon tracker to government surveillance highlights ongoing public concerns about privacy and data usage. However, in this case, the claims lack factual basis and misrepresent both the timing and purpose of the banking feature.
CoGo, the carbon-tracking firm partnered with NatWest for this initiative, declined to comment on the recent claims circulating on social media.
Verify This Yourself
Use these professional tools to fact-check and investigate claims independently
Reverse Image Search
Check if this image has been used elsewhere or in different contexts
Ask Our AI About This Claim
Get instant answers with web-powered AI analysis
Related Fact-Checks
See what other fact-checkers have said about similar claims
Want More Verification Tools?
Access our full suite of professional disinformation monitoring and investigation tools
10 Comments
The NatWest carbon footprint tracker is an interesting development, though the claims about it being linked to digital IDs seem far-fetched. It’s good to see banks making sustainability tools available, but the effectiveness will depend on how customers actually engage with and use the feature. Time will tell if it drives meaningful change.
Providing customers with a carbon footprint tracker in their banking app is a reasonable idea from NatWest. However, the claims about it being connected to digital IDs or broader government initiatives seem unfounded. We should focus on the actual features and functionality, rather than unsubstantiated conspiracy theories.
As an environmentally-conscious bank customer, I appreciate that NatWest is giving people the option to track their carbon footprint through their banking app. It’s a small but potentially meaningful step towards helping people understand and reduce their emissions from everyday spending. I’ll be curious to see if other banks follow suit.
While the NatWest carbon footprint tracker is a potentially useful tool, I’m skeptical of the conspiracy theories around it being tied to digital IDs or government overreach. Banking apps offering environmental data is a growing trend, but the implementation and impact remain to be seen. Fact-checking is important to separate truth from speculation.
The carbon footprint tracker seems like a useful feature for NatWest customers who want to monitor their environmental impact. However, the claims about it being connected to digital IDs or government initiatives appear to be unfounded conspiracy theories. It’s important to stick to the facts when discussing new banking services like this.
The NatWest carbon footprint tracker is an interesting sustainability initiative, though the claims about it being connected to digital IDs seem far-fetched. It’s good to see banks taking steps to provide customers with environmental data, but the effectiveness will depend on actual usage and behavior change, not just the existence of the feature.
I’m curious to learn more about how effective NatWest’s carbon footprint tracker has been since its launch in 2021. Voluntary tools that help people understand their environmental impact could be valuable, but the real test will be if they meaningfully influence consumer behavior over time. More data would be helpful to evaluate the tracker’s real-world impact.
Interesting to see NatWest offering a carbon footprint tracker in their app. It’s a voluntary service, not linked to any digital ID, so customers can use it to better understand their spending habits and environmental impact if they choose. Curious how effective it will be at driving behavior change.
While the NatWest carbon footprint tracker seems like a reasonable feature, the claims about it being connected to digital IDs or broader government initiatives are unfounded. We should focus on the factual details of what the tool actually does, rather than speculating about unproven conspiracy theories. Providing environmental data to customers could be helpful, but the real impact remains to be seen.
As someone concerned about climate change, I appreciate that NatWest is giving customers the option to track their carbon footprint through their banking app. However, the conspiracy theories around it being linked to digital IDs are baseless and distract from the potential value of such tools. I’ll be curious to see if other banks follow NatWest’s lead on this.