Listen to the article
In the wake of recent Tumbler Ridge shootings, RCMP officials have condemned the spread of false information that wrongly identified an Ontario woman as the suspect, highlighting growing concerns about online misinformation following violent incidents.
On Friday, RCMP Deputy Commissioner Dwayne McDonald publicly released a confirmed photo of the actual shooter, Jesse Van Rootselaar, while specifically addressing false accusations against an individual named Zylii Strang who had no connection to the case.
“Zylii — this did not need to happen. We know you are not involved,” McDonald stated during the briefing.
The misidentification appears to have stemmed from confusion over surnames. McDonald explained that the innocent person in Ontario had a similar name to someone associated with the crime, likely referring to the fact that the shooter’s mother, Jennifer Jacobs, also used the name Jennifer Strang.
According to Ahmed Al-Rawi, a professor in Simon Fraser University’s communication department who directs the Disinformation Project, the spread of misinformation was fueled by biases after it emerged the shooter was transgender.
“People were spreading images of innocent transgender people based on prejudices,” Al-Rawi explained. He noted that motivations behind sharing false information vary — some users seek financial gain through viral content, while others become immersed in conspiracy theories.
Krista Strang, speaking to French news agency Agence France-Presse, said her daughter Zylii is 25 years old — seven years older than Van Rootselaar — and has been “devastated” by the misidentification. The mother expressed bewilderment at how her daughter became linked to the crime, suggesting it may have been due to her being transgender and sharing the Strang surname.
“My child is afraid to go outside now,” Krista Strang told AFP.
Heidi Tworek, assistant professor at the University of British Columbia’s School of Public Policy and Global Affairs, noted that public curiosity about crime details before official information is released has always existed but has been “massively accelerated” by social media.
“We’ve seen in multiple cases, not just this one, these misidentifications of people that have had tremendous deleterious consequences for those innocent individuals who are not at all connected to these tragedies,” Tworek said.
The gap between official investigation timelines and public demand for immediate information creates fertile ground for conspiracy theories, Tworek explained. Social media platforms exacerbate this problem by increasing the likelihood that innocent people will be “caught in the crossfire.”
The incident has prompted community responses. British Columbia resident Melissa Antoinette has actively posted videos across multiple social media platforms urging people to remove misleading images of Strang.
“I feel absolutely terrible for anybody to have their image attached to any sort of horrific event or anything that they didn’t do,” Antoinette said. She reported having to flag numerous hateful comments to social media platforms.
Notably, some media organization reporters were among those who shared the incorrect images, further amplifying the misinformation.
Mark Deeley, a teacher at Tumbler Ridge Secondary School who has been praised for protecting his class during the shooting, addressed the issue on Facebook Sunday. He condemned using the tragedy to vilify transgender people.
“I do not and will not exacerbate the intolerance with hate. My humanity refuses it,” Deeley wrote. He emphasized that love is the only effective response to hate, adding: “We need voices that are louder than those who would deny someone’s right to exist as their true self.”
Deputy Commissioner McDonald acknowledged that the significant public attention to the Tumbler Ridge incident has heightened concern across many Canadian communities. While public engagement can help bring forward serious complaints, he cautioned that media coverage can also increase false reports.
The case highlights the broader societal challenge of balancing the public’s desire for information with the ethical responsibility to avoid spreading unverified claims that can cause real harm to innocent individuals.
Fact Checker
Verify the accuracy of this article using The Disinformation Commission analysis and real-time sources.
9 Comments
The RCMP’s actions to publicly correct the misinformation and protect the innocent individual are commendable. We must be vigilant in verifying information, especially when it involves sensitive cases and vulnerable people.
The RCMP’s swift response to correct the misinformation and protect the innocent individual is commendable. Spreading false claims, even with good intentions, can be extremely damaging. We need to be more vigilant about verifying information before sharing it online.
The RCMP’s clear response and identification of the actual shooter is commendable. Misidentifying innocent individuals on social media is a serious issue that can lead to real-world harm. More care and scrutiny is needed when discussing sensitive cases.
This is a concerning trend. Spreading false information during a sensitive time can do more harm than good. We need to be vigilant about verifying facts before sharing online, especially when it involves vulnerable individuals.
Absolutely. Rushing to judgment and making accusations without proof can have devastating consequences. It’s crucial that we rely on official sources and avoid perpetuating misinformation, even if it seems compelling.
This is a concerning trend that needs to be addressed. Spreading misinformation, even inadvertently, can have serious consequences. I hope the authorities and online platforms can work together to curb the spread of false claims and protect victims.
Agreed. Responsible social media use and fact-checking are crucial to prevent further harm. We must be cautious about perpetuating unverified narratives, no matter how tempting they may seem.
Concerns about online misinformation are valid, especially following violent incidents. While it’s understandable to want answers, spreading unverified claims can do more damage. I hope the authorities are able to fully address this issue and prevent further harm.
I agree. Responsible reporting and fact-checking are crucial to avoid fueling harmful narratives. Individuals should also be cautious about blindly sharing information without confirming its accuracy first.