Listen to the article
UN Special Rapporteur Falsely Accused After Doctored Video Spreads Online
Several European government officials have called for the resignation of UN Special Rapporteur Francesca Albanese based on remarks she never made, following the circulation of a deliberately edited video clip online.
The controversy erupted when a truncated clip appeared to show Albanese referring to Israel as “the common enemy of humanity.” This prompted immediate condemnation from high-ranking officials across Europe and the United States, with many demanding she step down from her position as Special Rapporteur for the human rights situation in Palestine.
Among those who publicly criticized Albanese were German Foreign Minister Johann Wadephul, who called her position “untenable”; French Foreign Minister Jean-Noel Barrot, who “unreservedly condemns the outrageous and reprehensible remarks”; and Italian Foreign Minister Antonio Tajani, who stated her “behaviours…are not appropriate for the position she holds.”
Other officials joined the chorus, including Czech Republic’s Foreign Minister Petr Macinka and US Ambassador Mike Waltz, who accused Albanese of antisemitism. Austrian Foreign Minister Beate Meinl-Reisinger went further, alleging that Albanese was spreading hate speech and failing to meet UN standards of impartiality.
However, multiple media outlets, including Reuters and France24, along with the UN Human Rights Office, have confirmed the video was doctored. According to the complete footage from an Al Jazeera roundtable event in Doha, Albanese never characterized Israel as “the enemy of humanity.”
In her actual remarks, Albanese stated: “We who do not control large amounts of financial capitals, algorithms and weapons, we now see that we as a humanity have a common enemy, and freedoms, the respect of fundamental freedoms is the last peaceful avenue, the last peaceful toolbox we have to regain our freedom.”
Marta Hurtado, spokesperson for the Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights, clarified during a press conference that Albanese “did not characterize any state as an enemy of humanity.” Hurtado expressed concern about the “personal attacks, threats and disinformation” targeting UN officials and independent experts, noting that such campaigns distract from serious human rights issues.
Albanese herself has rejected the accusations, clarifying on social media that “the common enemy of humanity is the system that has enabled the genocide in Palestine, including the financial capital that funds it, the algorithms that obscure it and the weapons that enable it.”
Evidence suggests the edited clip was initially shared by Hillel Neuer, executive director of UN Watch, a pro-Israel NGO that has repeatedly criticized Albanese since October 7, 2023, accusing her of being “antisemitic” and “pro-Hamas.” UN Watch did not respond to requests for comment about the source of the clip.
Amnesty International Secretary General Agnès Callamard has called for ministers to fully retract their demands for Albanese’s resignation. “It is reprehensible that ministers have attacked [Albanese] based on a deliberately truncated video to misrepresent and gravely misconstrue her messages,” Callamard stated.
The Association of Jurists for the Respect of International Law has filed a criminal complaint against French Foreign Minister Barrot, claiming his statements may violate French law regarding the dissemination of false information.
When contacted, only the German Federal Foreign Office responded, stating that Minister Wadephul “was referring to the statement as a whole, not to a manipulated video” and that Albanese has “repeatedly made statements and spread untenable falsehoods in the past.”
This incident comes amid Albanese’s ongoing work documenting what she has termed Israel’s “genocidal campaign in Gaza.” In June 2025, she published a report examining corporate involvement in sustaining Israel’s military operations, highlighting how companies including IBM, Microsoft, Alphabet, Amazon, and Palantir have supplied technologies that enable “mass violence and immense destruction.”
The Austrian Foreign Minister has since deleted her post accusing Albanese of spreading hate speech, while Albanese continues to face restrictions from a 2025 Trump administration sanction that prevents her from accessing US-based bank accounts or traveling to the United States.
Fact Checker
Verify the accuracy of this article using The Disinformation Commission analysis and real-time sources.
14 Comments
Knee-jerk reactions to edited footage can lead to serious consequences. I’d like to see the full, unedited video and hear the Rapporteur’s side of the story before forming an opinion on this matter.
Well said. Responsible leadership requires due diligence, not hasty condemnation based on incomplete information.
This seems like a clear case of misinformation being used for political purposes. I hope the facts come to light and the Rapporteur is given a chance to respond appropriately.
Absolutely. Spreading unverified claims, especially against UN officials, undermines trust in our institutions. Cool heads and careful analysis are needed here.
I hope the authorities investigate this incident thoroughly and ensure the Rapporteur is given a fair hearing. Rushing to judgment based on edited footage is unwise and undermines the integrity of our institutions.
Well said. Maintaining a commitment to facts and due process, even in the face of political pressure, is essential for upholding the rule of law.
It’s troubling to see high-ranking officials so quickly condemn the UN Rapporteur without verifying the facts. This type of behavior erodes public trust and undermines the integrity of our institutions.
Well said. Responsible leadership requires a commitment to due process and a respect for the rule of law, even when it’s politically inconvenient.
It’s troubling to see politicians so quickly jump on the bandwagon to condemn the UN Rapporteur without verifying the facts. This type of behavior erodes public faith in our leaders.
Agreed. Responsible governance requires a commitment to truth and due process, not knee-jerk reactions to partial information.
This is a concerning example of how disinformation can be weaponized for political ends. I hope the truth comes to light and the Rapporteur is afforded the opportunity to respond to these allegations.
Agreed. In these divisive times, it’s crucial that we strive for objectivity and fairness, rather than jumping to conclusions based on partial information.
This is a concerning case of the spread of disinformation. It’s important to verify facts and context before making accusations, especially against UN officials. I hope this gets resolved through proper channels and due process.
Agreed, rushing to judgment based on doctored video clips is irresponsible. The UN Rapporteur deserves a fair hearing to address these allegations.